Go Unlimited with Magzter GOLD
Get unlimited access to 10,000+ magazines, newspapers and Premium stories for just
THE CASE OF THE AI-GENERATED GIANT RAT PENIS
Reason magazine
|June 2024
HOW DID AN OBVIOUSLY FABRICATED ARTICLE END UP IN A PEER-REVIEWED JOURNAL?
AN ILLUSTRATION FEATURING a rat with a cross section of a giant penis set off a firestorm of criticism about the use of generative artificial intelligence based on large language models (LLMs) in scientific publishing. The bizarre illustration was embellished with nonsense labels, including one fortuitously designated as “dck.” The article on rat testes stem cells had undergone peer review and editorial vetting before being published in February by Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology.
“Mayday,” blared longtime AI researcher and critic Gary Marcus on X (formerly known as Twitter). Vexed by AI’s ability to abet the “exponential enshittification of science,” he added, “the sudden pollution of science with LLM-generated content, known to yield plausible-sounding but sometimes difficult to detect errors (‘hallucinations’) is serious, and its impact will be lasting.”
A February 2024 article in
This story is from the June 2024 edition of Reason magazine.
Subscribe to Magzter GOLD to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 10,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MORE STORIES FROM Reason magazine
Reason magazine
Does AI Know How You Will Die?
HOW HIGH IS your risk of developing pancreatic cancer or suffering a heart attack in the next 20 years? A new generative artificial intelligence system called Delphi-2M aims to answer that question and offer personalized forecasts of your long-term health trajectory.
1 mins
February/March 2026
Reason magazine
SOUTH PARK
The animated TV comedy South Park continues to do the impossible: stay punchy and relevant after decades on the air. The latest five-episode season, streaming on Paramount+, once again follows the fourth-graders of South Park Elementary as they navigate a world increasingly obsessed with technology and everything political.
1 min
February/March 2026
Reason magazine
WILL MAMDANI DEFUND THE POLICE?
THE NEW MAYOR IS KEEPING POLICE COMMISSIONER JESSICA TISCH ON THE JOB, BUT THEY MIGHT HAVE A CONTENTIOUS RELATIONSHIP.
3 mins
February/March 2026
Reason magazine
MAMDANI'S EDUCATION AGENDA FOR LESS LEARNING
NEW YORK SCHOOLS NEED MORE CHOICE AND BETTER CURRICULA, BUT THE CITY'S NEW MAYOR WANTS TO TAKE CHOICES AWAY.
8 mins
February/March 2026
Reason magazine
THE TWO FACES OF ZOHRAN MAMDANI
MAMDANI ACTUALLY WANTS MORE HOUSING TO BE BUILT.
3 mins
February/March 2026
Reason magazine
The Long Road Home
The Wounded Generation examines the aftermath of the “good war.”
5 mins
February/March 2026
Reason magazine
How the FCC Became the Speech Police
THE CONSTITUTIONALLY ANOMALOUS STATUS OF BROADCASTING INVITES GOVERNMENT MEDDLING.
21 mins
February/March 2026
Reason magazine
MAMDANI CAN'T RAISE YOUR KIDS
THE MORE THE GOVERNMENT INTERVENES IN THE MARKET, THE MORE NEW YORK PARENTS PAY FOR CHILD CARE.
10 mins
February/March 2026
Reason magazine
Ayn Rand, the Video Game
\"WHAT DOES COMPLETELY, COMPLETELY UNREGULATED COMMERCE LOOK LIKE?\" KEN LEVINE'S BIOSHOCK WILL TELL YOU.
14 mins
February/March 2026
Reason magazine
DEATH BY LIGHTNING
Mike Makowsky opens Death by Lightning, a four-part miniseries he wrote and produced, with a chilling line: “This is a true story about two men the world forgot. One was the 20th president of the United States. The other shot him.” Yet this drama about President James Garfield and assassin Charles Guiteau reminds us that we should wish for more forgettable presidents.
1 min
February/March 2026
Listen
Translate
Change font size