Versuchen GOLD - Frei
Dealing With The Bias In SA's Labour Tenancy Claims System
Farmer's Weekly
|May 31, 2019
Based on his extensive experience in representing mostly KwaZulu-Natal landowners in labour tenancy claims lodged against them, attorney Rob McCarthy of McCarthy and Associates believes the process is inherently biased in favour of claimants. He speaks to Lloyd Phillips about this challenge, and gives landowners advice on how best to fight false labour tenancy claims.
-
WHAT IS THE STATUS OF LABOUR TENANCY CLAIMS IN SOUTH AFRICA?
In 2003 or thereabouts, the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform (DRDLR) sent labour tenancy claims and associated notices in terms of Section 17 of the Land Reform (Labour Tenants) Act 3 of 1996 to affected landowners. My law firm was tasked by landowners with handling just over 1 600 of these claims throughout KwaZulu-Natal (KZN) and a small number in adjacent provinces. I was told that there were about 7 000 labour tenancy claims throughout South Africa. During the past three or so years, the Association for Rural Advancement (AFRA) took the DRDLR to the Land Claims Court (LCC) as a class action to represent labour tenancy applicants in general, and achieved a court order compelling the DRDLR to process and finalise the many claims outstanding since 2003.
As I understand it, AFRA subsequently had to go back to the LCC to get an order for contempt of court against the DRDLR because of the department’s failure to implement the original court order. If there’s one thing that the DRDLR has repeatedly proven that it’s good at, it’s to prevaricate.
Over the past three years, I’ve seen a growing number of Section 17 notices being delivered on landowners by the DRDLR. I believe that this is as a result of pressure being brought to bear on the department by organisations such as AFRA, due to political pressure with respect to land reform, and due to the growing expectations of labour tenancy claimants who have been waiting for up to 15 years.
WHAT PROBLEMS HAVE YOU FOUND IN YOUR DEALINGS WITH THE DRDLR REGARDING LABOUR TENANCY CLAIMS?
Diese Geschichte stammt aus der May 31, 2019-Ausgabe von Farmer's Weekly.
Abonnieren Sie Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierter Premium-Geschichten und über 9.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.
Sie sind bereits Abonnent? Anmelden
WEITERE GESCHICHTEN VON Farmer's Weekly
Farmer's Weekly
The foot-and-mouth disease threat is growing
Foot-and-mouth disease poses a growing threat to the livestock industry, especially communal farmers, with devastating economic consequences unless awareness and compliance improve, writes Shane Brody.
3 mins
January 30 - February 06, 2026
Farmer's Weekly
Shipping conditions to ease in 2026, but risk remains high
Early signs suggest a more favourable export season for South African producers, as easing global shipping congestion and improved performance by Transnet point to higher throughput at local ports. Lindi Botha reports.
2 mins
January 30 - February 06, 2026
Farmer's Weekly
A path of accelerating land reform in South Africa
Delivering the ANC's January 8th Statement a few weeks ago, President Cyril Ramaphosa noted, amongst other things, that: “Land reform remains one of the most urgent tasks of the National Democratic Revolution. While progress has been made, much more is required to give effect to the constitutional requirement for redress and equitable access to land.”
2 mins
January 30 - February 06, 2026
Farmer's Weekly
Reflections on 2025 and the policy space for 2026
The year 2025 was a year characterised initially by a wave of misinformation, particularly relating to legislation and tariff issues. This year some big moves are expected in the trade space.
3 mins
January 30 - February 06, 2026
Farmer's Weekly
From planning to peak lay: building a profitable egg business
Mpumalanga poultry farmer Lebogang Mashego spoke to Octavia Avesca Spandiel, and shared practical insights on planning, building systems that work, breed choice, feed management, and markets to build a profitable and sustainable egg business.
5 mins
January 30 - February 06, 2026
Farmer's Weekly
Impofu Wind Farm becomes a canvas for community connection through Enel's Blowing Art Initiative
Enel Green Power South Africa has introduced the Blowing Art Initiative at the Impofu Wind Farm in the Eastern Cape, a creative community project that turns renewable energy infrastructure into a living gallery.
2 mins
January 30 - February 06, 2026
Farmer's Weekly
Geely is intent on hanging around
Having fallen off the radar around a decade ago following a short local stint, Chinese manufacturer Geely has announced its proposed return to South Africa towards the end of 2026. The Citizen's Jaco van der Merwe reports.
4 mins
January 30 - February 06, 2026
Farmer's Weekly
Great reads to enjoy during ‘me-time'
Patricia McCracken has plucked an assortment of fascinating titles covering different areas of interest, from coastal exploration and dining in the wild, to African traditions surrounding love and marriage.
3 mins
January 30 - February 06, 2026
Farmer's Weekly
Thokoman Peanut Butter marks 25-year milestone with R500 000 commitment to food security
Thokoman Peanut Butter, one of South Africa's biggest producers of peanut butter, celebrates 25 years of consistent quality and community support, marking the occasion with a significant R500 000 partnership with Hot 102.7's Hot Cares initiative for 2026.
2 mins
January 30 - February 06, 2026
Farmer's Weekly
South Africa's famous wandering hippo
From 1928 to 1931, a hippopotamus trekked 1 600km from what was then northern Natal to the Eastern Cape's Keiskamma River near Peddie, where it was shot dead by a posse of farmers. As Mike Burgess writes, this journey would immortalise the hippo in South African history.
3 mins
January 30 - February 06, 2026
Translate
Change font size