EVERYONE'S FALLING FOR PAUL

AUDIENCES ARE HAVING THEIR OWN LOVE STORY WITH THE MAN BRINGING JFK JR. TO LIFE

- • By Kylie Walters

Cycling through the streets of Tribeca in a dark suit and a Kangol hat on backwards, it's easy to forget - just for a moment - that you're watching Paul Anthony Kelly play JFK Jr. in Love Story and not the political dynasty's magnetic heir himself. With his dark curls, angular jaw and sharply carved cheekbones, Kelly bears such an uncanny resemblance that it's easy to imagine New Yorkers double-taking as they wandered past the Ryan Murphy production mid-shoot.

The only real criticism of the casting? Could Kelly, 37, actually be better looking than John F. Kennedy Jr. ever was?

"How hot is too hot?" GQ teased at the start of a recent cover story on the rising star. The journalist may have been referring to the menu at the Cantonese restaurant where the pair talked over lunch, but the line remains a fair question. Kelly's classic, preppy good looks and charisma have made him Hollywood's newest obsession.