'BBC bosses pulled our film on Israel attacking Gaza's medics. Here's why'
The Observer
|July 13, 2025
The inside story of how the corporation repeatedly delayed and ultimately shelved a damning documentary is revealed by producer Ben de Pear and its narrator Ramita Navai
-
"Ramita, oh, how brilliant that you're here." The senior BBC executives could not mask their surprise that Ramita Navai, the reporter of the film they had commissioned on the destruction of Gaza's health service, had turned up to a meeting they had not invited her to.
They had not invited her because, as it turned out, the point of the meeting was to set her up as the fall guy.
It was early May. We were executive producers of a documentary, Gaza: Doctors Under Attack, directed by Karim Shah. On the agenda for the meeting at new Broadcasting House was the BBC's decision to pull the film for the final time, days before its scheduled broadcast.
This was the sixth time the BBC had stopped the release of our film, a yearlong investigation into Israel's targeting of Palestinian doctors and the healthcare system in Gaza.
The film had been completed, delivered, approved by lawyers and editors, and praised by the bosses, but then its release began to be repeatedly delayed.
The reasons given for the delays we faced in fact had little to do with our film and more to do with another one: How to Survive a Warzone. An internal investigation had been launched after it emerged that the child who narrated the film was the son of a junior Hamas minister in Gaza.
Now the BBC was anxious because it had another Gaza film on its hands: one showing that doctors, medics and hospitals were being targeted and killed by Israel, made by a production company working hand in glove with two of its own journalists.
Our film had been, in effect, shelved, but after two months of "inadvertently leading us on" (their words), one of the executives in this May meeting laid out a plan for a possible solution: to downgrade Ramita's role as correspondent to that of a "contributor" or "third party reporter".
Bu hikaye The Observer dergisinin July 13, 2025 baskısından alınmıştır.
Binlerce özenle seçilmiş premium hikayeye ve 9.000'den fazla dergi ve gazeteye erişmek için Magzter GOLD'a abone olun.
Zaten abone misiniz? Oturum aç
The Observer'den DAHA FAZLA HİKAYE
The Observer
The smart course
Britain needs an Australian-style social media ban
2 mins
December 14, 2025
The Observer
Sophie Kinsella
Novelist who turned the everyday chaos of modern womanhood into bestselling, big-hearted comedy
4 mins
December 14, 2025
The Observer
Private schools charge councils up to £250k for each Send pupil
International investors are raking in millions from local authorities because mainstream schools cannot provide for the soaring number of children who need specialist support
5 mins
December 14, 2025
The Observer
Here's Johnny! The return of a Hollywood star too big to cancel
After a spectacular fall from grace, Johnny Depp will play Scrooge — a cruel man forced to reckon with his past. Alexi Mostrous reports on a startling comeback
5 mins
December 14, 2025
The Observer
Trump has decisive views on Europe – and we cannot afford to ignore them
Compare and contrast these words from two American presidents.
4 mins
December 14, 2025
The Observer
Uncertainty over budget leaves holiday hangover
Christmas and New Year is often a busy period for family law offices - the unhappy reason being separations and divorce enquiries spike this time of year.
1 mins
December 14, 2025
The Observer
Nato allies' €1bn fund for defence startups suffers early casualties
A €1bn venture capital (VC) fund to invest in defence startups and backed by Nato allies has lost four of its five founding partners, as well as its chair, in the past 18 months.
2 mins
December 14, 2025
The Observer
Keir Starmer flinches from the alarming truth that the United States no longer behaves like a friend
Trumpian aggression towards America's traditional allies has become a menace that cannot be ignored
4 mins
December 14, 2025
The Observer
Starmer joins Euro leaders in bid to change US peace plan for Ukraine
Keir Starmer is expected to head to Berlin tomorrow for crucial talks on the future of Ukraine with fellow European leaders, Volodymyr Zelensky and Donald Trump’s envoy Steve Witkoff.
1 mins
December 14, 2025
The Observer
"Many children are captivated by Hitler. Few remain obsessed for so long
Like Nigel Farage, as a teenager I was obsessed with Hitler and the second world war.
2 mins
December 14, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size

