Denemek ALTIN - Özgür
Why Poverty Hasn't Led To Social Unrest
The New Indian Express Kozhikode
|August 15, 2025
It's a puzzle why the immiserated haven't risen in popular revolt. Disaggregated govt handouts have helped in patches. It isn't utopian to consider a more stable solution
To read the pervasive commentary in the economic sections of the world's newspapers on what the globalising neoliberal turn in political economy has wrought in the last few decades in India, one would think that it has all been for the good—its economy has been growing, as has the middle class, and poverty has been reduced.
Yet, serious economic analysis has fundamentally challenged this as, in one crucial respect, downright false. Measurement of poverty in India, by criteria that are sound rather than skewed, points to increased immiseration of the worst-off in numbers as large as ever, despite a swelling middle class.
A puzzle arises then as to why, given this growing immiseration, there has been no explosion of social unrest. A familiar answer points to how people are deflected from their suffering by the Hindutva politics of identity. There is, no doubt, some truth in this. But deflections of that sort cannot for long prevent the intolerability of the suffering—especially if it is as extreme as studies have shown it to be—from prompting popular anger and agency. So, the puzzle remains.
In recent years, the influential work of economist Kalyan Sanyal implies a different explanation. Its argument in summary is this. Capitalism of recent decades in India dispossesses the peasants from their land, but cannot absorb them in industrial labour, as was done in Europe in earlier centuries (nor even in what Karl Marx called the 'reserve army'). It thus creates a very large population which is outside of the corporate capitalist political economy, hence unable to morph into a unified class formation with the familiar potential for forging the agencies of resistance attributed to the 'proletariat' in an earlier phase of capitalism.
Bu hikaye The New Indian Express Kozhikode dergisinin August 15, 2025 baskısından alınmıştır.
Binlerce özenle seçilmiş premium hikayeye ve 9.000'den fazla dergi ve gazeteye erişmek için Magzter GOLD'a abone olun.
Zaten abone misiniz? Oturum aç
The New Indian Express Kozhikode'den DAHA FAZLA HİKAYE

The New Indian Express Kozhikode
MP uses chopper-driven technique to protect crops from blackbucks
THE Madhya Pradesh forest department has initiated a helicopter-driven boma technique to capture herds of blackbucks and neelgais and shift them to wildlife sanctuaries and tiger reserves of the state.
1 mins
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Kozhikode
WASTE LAND: A NATION OF LANDFILLS
SOME years ago, I was editing a newspaper in Mumbai and we ran a report on the city’s eternal garbage problem.
3 mins
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Kozhikode
10 months on, NMC yet to act against 30 docs for 'sponsored' foreign trips
THE National Medical Commission (NMC) is yet to take any action against 30 doctors who accepted free trips to Monaco and Paris worth ₹1.91 crore last year, despite the Department of Pharmaceuticals (DoP) recommendations that action should be taken against them for violating professional misconduct.
1 mins
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Kozhikode
Relief as $1L H-1B fee does not apply to US visa holders
A month after US President Donald Trump’s proclamation jacking up the fee for H1-B visas to a steep $100,000 caused panic among international students and professionals, the US government has now clarified that the fee won’t apply to most current visa holders and recent international graduates.
1 min
October 22, 2025

The New Indian Express Kozhikode
7 Punjab youths duped in Kazakhstan, appeal for help
SEVEN young men from Punjab’s Ropar district are stranded in Kazakhstan after a local travel agent allegedly duped them by promising high-paying jobs as drivers.
1 mins
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Kozhikode
PK SAYS BJP FORCING HIS CANDIDATES TO OPT OUT OF CONTEST
JAN Suraaj Party (JSP) founder Prashant Kishor on Tuesday launched a scathing attack on BJP alleging that three of his party candidates for the upcoming Bihar Assembly elections withdrew their nominations under “pressure” from the ruling party.
1 min
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Kozhikode
Price rise no deterrent, temples glitter in gold offerings
EVEN AS gold prices surge to record highs, Kerala's temples continue to glitter with the devotion of followers. Offerings of gold and silver pour in undeterred.
1 mins
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Kozhikode
EC: Print ads a day before or poll date need pre-certification
AHEAD of assembly polls in Bihar, the Election Commission of India (ECI) on Tuesday issued an order saying to ensure a fair campaign environment, no party, candidate, organisation or person shall publish any advertisement in print media on poll day and one day prior to the poll day, unless the contents are pre-certified by the Media Certification and Monitoring Committee.
1 min
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Kozhikode
Post-Diwali air quality in Delhi worst in 4 years
Revellers flouted time limit for firecrackers
1 mins
October 22, 2025

The New Indian Express Kozhikode
FIR against former Punjab DGP, ex-minister wife over son’s death
FORMER Punjab DGP Mohammad Mustafa, his wife and former minister Razia Sultana, along with their daughter and daughter-in-law, have been booked for murder and criminal conspiracy by Haryana Police in connection with the death of their 35-year-old son, Agil Akhter.
1 mins
October 22, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size