Denemek ALTIN - Özgür
Who Gets To Impose Uniform Civil Code?
The Morning Standard
|March 29, 2025
State assemblies don't seem to have the legislative competence to enact a Uniform Civil Code. It appears to be just another politically opportune and socially divisive move
Today, let's explore whether any state in the Union of India has the authority to enact and enforce a Uniform Civil Code. Article 44 of the Constitution is part of the Directive Principles of State Policy. At the time of framing of the Constitution, there was no Uniform Civil Code in place. Given the diversity of India, there were several laws and customs of communities, including religious communities, in place. It is in this context that Article 44 was drafted, mandating, "The State shall endeavour to secure for the citizens a Uniform Civil Code throughout the territory of India."
There are three expressions in this provision that require attention. First is the word "State", second is the expression "endeavour to secure" for its "citizens", and the third is the "Uniform Civil Code throughout the territory of India".
The "State" here means not a state government, but the Union of India, since such a law, if framed by the Union, will be applicable throughout the territory of India. That cannot happen if the law is framed by a state government. The second clue that the State means the Union of India comes from the expression "citizens". We all know that the status of citizenship is granted only by the Union. Those residing within a state are not its citizens.
Article 44 further mandates that the "State", meaning the Union of India, shall endeavour to enact a Uniform Civil Code. It seems clear to me that a state government cannot, under its legislative powers, enact a law pursuant to the mandate under Article 44 of the Constitution.
It is, therefore, clear that any provision under the Uniform Civil Code, Uttarakhand, 2024, which applies to the residents of Uttarakhand, excluding tribals, would fall foul of the laws framed by the Union of India.
Bu hikaye The Morning Standard dergisinin March 29, 2025 baskısından alınmıştır.
Binlerce özenle seçilmiş premium hikayeye ve 9.000'den fazla dergi ve gazeteye erişmek için Magzter GOLD'a abone olun.
Zaten abone misiniz? Oturum aç
The Morning Standard'den DAHA FAZLA HİKAYE
The Morning Standard
Local touch: Man of the hour Ishan’s rise
Practice sessions with state team have helped him thrive at big stage
3 mins
February 17, 2026
The Morning Standard
FROM TALENT SOURCE TO STUDY HUB
FOR decades, the story of Indian higher education has been shaped as much by what happens beyond the country’s borders as by what unfolds within its classrooms.
3 mins
February 17, 2026
The Morning Standard
SAVE CHILD NUTRITION FROM CASTE PREJUDICE
IN Nuagaon village of Odisha’s Kendrapara district, Sarmista Sethi’s forlorn figure at the anganwadi centre, ready to cook a meal but with no child willing to eat it, will remain a lasting image of the deeply entrenched caste prejudice prevalent in India.
1 mins
February 17, 2026
The Morning Standard
'Disturbing': SC junks pleas on Himanta
THE Supreme Court on Monday refused to entertain a batch of petitions filed by CPI and CPM leaders against Assam CM Himanta Biswa Sarma over a viral video showing him taking aim and firing a gun at members of a particular community.
1 min
February 17, 2026
The Morning Standard
HC: Elderly parents can’t be forced to suffer harassment in own home
IN a significant ruling, the Jharkhand High Court has said that elderly parents cannot be forced to tolerate harassment in their own homes.
1 min
February 17, 2026
The Morning Standard
Mann back to hosp amid Punjab cabinet rejig buzz
PUNJAB Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann attended an AAP rally on Monday as part of the state government's anti-drug campaign, amid growing rumours of a cabinet reshuffle.
1 min
February 17, 2026
The Morning Standard
‘5th-gen fighter imports not the answer’
Instead focus should be on weapons delivery range and effectiveness, says Air Vice Marshal Anil Golani (Retd)
3 mins
February 17, 2026
The Morning Standard
Bhagwat call to work for larger Hindu society
Says Sangh speaks for community as every Indian connected to it
1 mins
February 17, 2026
The Morning Standard
State’s plea against retrospective pay hike for HC law researchers rejected
THE Supreme Court on Monday dismissed the Delhi government’s appeal against a Delhi High Court order that directed retrospective payment of enhanced remuneration to law researchers attached to the High Court.
1 mins
February 17, 2026
The Morning Standard
EC suspends 7 Bengal officials working on SIR for ‘serious misconduct’
THE Election Commission has ordered the immediate suspension of seven officials of the West Bengal government at the level of Assistant Electoral Registration Officer (AEROs) for “serious misconduct, dereliction of duty and misuse of statutory powers” in connection with the ongoing SIR of electoral rolls in the state.
1 min
February 17, 2026
Listen
Translate
Change font size
