Why did you accept the Rajya Sabha nomination so soon after demitting the office of the Chief Justice of India? Shouldn’t there have been a cooling-off period?
A. Why should I not have accepted it? When the president of the country makes an offer under Article 80, you don’t refuse it. When the nation wants your services, should you refuse that? As far as a cooling-off period is concerned, tell me, under what law or rule can the cooling-off period be visualised? If [it] is required, please make a law for [it]. Also, if a cooling-off period is applied, how do you [then] man the tribunals that have to be headed by retired Supreme Court judges? It is for the executive or the policymakers to prescribe a norm for cooling-off.
Q. In March 2019, you had said that post-retirement appointments are a blot on the independence of the judiciary. What changed?
A. Do you think a Rajya Sabha seat is a job? My statement was in the context of a judgment which dealt with tribunalisation. It’s not a job. It’s a recognition and an expectation that you will contribute in your field of expertise.
Q. When you were being sworn in, opposition parties walked off, crying ‘Shame!’. How do you react to that?
A. No reaction. It was expected. Opposition parties walk in and walk out. I don’t see how that can disturb any reasonable person.
Q. It’s not just opposition parties. Several former judges have suggested that your nomination was a sinecure for those verdicts during your tenure that favoured the Modi government—such as in the Ram Janmabhoomi case and the Rafale deal.
Bu hikaye India Today dergisinin April 06, 2020 sayısından alınmıştır.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Giriş Yap
Bu hikaye India Today dergisinin April 06, 2020 sayısından alınmıştır.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Giriş Yap
The Macallan M 2023 debuts in India
Standing as a pinnacle of exclusivity, The Macallan M 2023 graces the shores of India with limited 10 handpicked bottles for whisky aficionados
Give it up for the science bros
They've got brains, brawn and billions in the bank. A new breed of wellness guru is doing for men what Gwyneth Paltrow did for women.
LIVING BY THE RULES
Chetan Bhagat returns to non-fiction with his new book-11 Rules for Life
The Mysterious City
Anuradha Kumar's The Kidnapping of Mark Twain paints an intriguing portrait of Bombay around the time of the American writer's visit
GOWDA KNOWS
Hot Stage, the third book in Anita Nair's Inspector Gowda mystery series, is here
WITH OUR OWN DESI SLEUTHS
Indian detective fiction gets its due in this massive, two-volume compilation from Hachette
PRIVATE PARADISE
Your home may well be your haven, but here are easy ways to make it your very own spa-dom.
Subversive IN SUBURBIA
A MONTH-LONG SHOW AT ART AND CHARLIE, MUMBAI, SHOWCASING THE WORKS OF POONAM JAIN AND YOGESH BARVE POSES SEVERAL QUESTIONS TO THE VIEWER
THE HOME THAT WAS
A soon-to-launch gallery at the Partition Museum in Delhi will showcase artefacts capturing 'The Lost Homeland of Sindh'
The Enchanted Forest
A perfect refuge for city-weary folk, Six Senses Vana, the global brand's first dedicated wellness retreat in India, is where you go to retrieve yourself: Rest, reset and rejuvenate, the blockbuster RRR of the wellness universe.