Free Speech? Or Hate Speech?
Grazia SA|August 24 2016

A Canadian comic has been fined $42 000 by Canada’s Human Rights Commission – for making nasty jokes about a youngster with a disability. We canvassed a few contrasting opinions…

Alyn Adams

IN 2005, then-eight-year-old Canadian Jérémy Gabriel, who has Treacher Collins syndrome, realised a dream of singing for the pope. Treacher Collins causes facial disfiguration. Deafness is also a symptom, so it was miraculous that Jérémy could sing at all.

He achieved minor celebrity status in Canada, particularly in his native Quebec. He sang with Céline Dion and also performed the national anthem before an international ice hockey match. Six years later, Jérémy was still a celebrity, albeit in the patronising, over-exposed, “disability porn” sense that South Africans bestowed on progeria sufferer Fransie Geringer.

That’s when Mike Ward, a Canadian comic who loves “dark” material, made fun of Jérémy at the Nasty Show, a hardcore event during Montréal’s annual Just For Laughs/ Juste Pour Rire Festival.

He claimed that Jérémy was a Reach for a Dream kid, implying that he had a terminal illness, and Mike wanted to know why he wasn’t dead yet, because he found Jérémy’s frequent appearances so annoying. He went on to claim that the child was “unkillable”, as he, Mike, had “tried to drown him once”. His punchline? “I looked up what his disability is – turns out, it’s that he’s ugly.”

Jérémy and his mom were devastated. The boy claimed that Mike’s widely publicised jokes caused him to be bullied at school and resulted in so much personal anguish that he considered suicide. They approached the Canadian Human Rights Commission (HRC) in 2012, and earlier this year the HRC ruled that Mike had infringed on the “dignity, honour and reputation” of a disabled person. He was ordered to pay Jérémy and his mother $42 000 (R435 000) in moral and punitive damages.

The verdict kicked off a furore, with anti-hate-speech campaigners and disabled rights activists arguing with free-speech activists and comics claiming that the right to comment freely on public figures was being infringed. Mike is appealing the ruling, arguing that he has been punished for treating a disabled person “just like anyone else”.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

RELATED STORIES

Man About Town

TUNE IN! Mayor of Kingstown returns Sunday, Jan. 15, on Paramount+.

1 min read
Closer US
January 16, 2023

ROCK COMMANDO

Mike Shaw built this '67 Jeepster Commando with the help of his grandson Clay. Mike and his son Chris are avid off-roaders and have spent many days and nights working on project vehicles over the years, but this project was different.

3 mins read
Four Wheeler
February 2023

Their handmade toys bring joy to thousands of kids!

After retiring, Mike Sullivan felt lost. Then he remembered his greatest-ever Christmas gift: a wooden toy his father had made for him by hand. Suddenly an idea took root, and with his wife's help, Mike decided to fill his days by making thousands of wooden toys for children in need

3 mins read
Woman's World
December 12, 2022

Across the Universe

Chloé creative director Gabriela Hearst is drawing fashion inspiration from clean energy and the results are electrifying

10+ mins read
Vanity Fair US
December 2022 - January 2023

The Finish Line

Over more than a decade of covering politics, Annie Karni has seen the human side of campaigns and learned that losses teach us as much about ourselves, and our candidates, as victories do.

2 mins read
Vogue US
December 2022

Cold water swimming for triathletes

As temperatures drop, is there any benefit to swimming in cold water as triathletes, or should you stick to the pool? From cold hands to the afterdrop, we explore the chillier side of open water...

9 mins read
220 Triathlon
December 2022

Mikel Alonso y Alberto Ituarte

Presentan un hot spot renovado en el que suman talento y experiencia de más de 20 añosen el mundo de la hospitalidad, invitándote a vivir agradables experiencias.

3 mins read
Caras México
Noviembre 2022

Suddenly Sorta Spielberg

Gabriel LaBelle beat out 2,000 actors toplay a version of the famed director as a teen by embracing the meta-ness.

6 mins read
New York magazine
October 24 - November 6, 2022

The New Gods of the World Cup

From Tokyo to Rio, Munich to Mexico City, GQ presents its starting lineup of the most electric players to watch at Qatar 2022.

10+ mins read
GQ US
November 2022

Meet Mike Krzyzewski, Retiree

Even without his whistle, it turns out that the greatest hoops coach of all time still likes to let you know who's in charge

2 mins read
Esquire US
October - November 2022