Ro-railers Ahead Of Their Time Or Overtaken By Events?
The Railway Magazine|February 2018

A new type of vehicle for use on both road and rail was trialled in the early 1930s, but never caught on. Alan Dale considers whether early road-rail vehicles were too advanced for their time.

The Ro-railer, or road-rail vehicle, is an innovation that has flickered in and out of fashion and topicality, with changing social and economic conditions. The first Karrier Motors single-deck ro-rail bus of 1931 was a short-lived experiment that was never developed beyond the prototype.

The same applied to the ro-rail lorry trialled briefly by the LNER. The covered road tractor or locomotive-hauled ro-rail vans of the 1960s had a similarly brief life.

The ro-rail bus was introduced by the LMS after the company had bought the Grade II*-listed 19th century neo-Jacobean mansion Welcombe House, in Stratford-upon-Avon. This acquisition followed the death of Sir George Otto Trevelyan in 1928. Sir George, father of the eminent historian George Macaulay Trevelyan, had married Caroline Needham Phillips, of whose estate the house had formed part. The LMS considerably enlarged and extended the house, opening it as The Welcombe Hotel in 1931.

Road and rail

The bus was a single decker, designed by J Shearman, a road motor engineer of the LMS, and built by Karrier Motors of Huddersfield, with bodywork by Cravens of Sheffield. It was equipped with manually interchangeable rail and road wheels. Introduced early in 1932, it operated on the Stratford-upon-Avon and Midland Junction Railway line (SMJ), between Blisworth and the Stratford-on-Avon goods yard. The road wheels were lowered here, with the rail wheels raised clear of the road surface, by means of the interchanging mechanism and elongated spanners. The bus then proceeded by road to the Welcombe Hotel on the northern outskirts of the town. The service only ran for a few months.

Cravens built the body, providing a forward vestibule with 14 front-facing seats and a rear smoking saloon that contained 12 longitudinal ones. Some of the latter could be folded to augment the roof luggage space.

Karrier Motors also built a flat-bed lorry ro-railer for the LNER. This had fixed sides and a removable, hinged tailboard, giving inside body dimensions of 11ft 2in by 6ft 7in. A sanding device improved rail adhesion, thereby preventing wheel-lock and skating, while allowing optimum use of the servo-assisted brakes. The wheel interchange mechanism, on all four wheels, was the Karrier ‘C’ slot-type. This incorporated notable advances on the eccentric-based design utilised in the original system. An inner hub carried each pneumatic-tyred road wheel, plus a cranked sleeve that had the road wheel’s ‘C’ slotted outer hub mounted upon it.

Permanent way staff used this unit to take men and materials to site from their depot. It travelled by road to a point where it was convenient to access the track. Conversion to rail mode allowed access to sections of line with unsuitable or distant roads, such as between Bridge of Orchy to Tulloch, or Fort William to Mallaig.

Karrier’s LMS experimental bus design highlights the extent to which road and rail technology of the time could be effectively combined. Powered by a 37.2hp petrol engine, the transmission gave top gear ratios of 7:1 and 4.2:1 for road and rail, respectively. Recorded fuel consumptions were 8mpg for road and 16 for rail. The wheelbase of 17ft 1in and road wheel track of 6ft 3½ for the bus reflect its 26-seat capacity. It was designed to carry three tons in total (i.e. passengers, luggage and crew). This specification complied with the Ministry of Transport and railway regulations.

These dimensions compare intriguingly with the length and capacity of later railbuses and DMU carriages. The five Park Royal railbuses, for example, were 42ft long and seated 50, but without the ability to use the roads.

Eccentrics

The wheel interchange mechanism comprised axles that extended through the rail wheels to the front and rear outer pair of road wheels. The latter were mounted on eccentrics, hence their centres were eccentric to those of their rail counterparts. The rail wheels, being smaller than the road ones, could be locked, concentrically to the road wheels, clear of the road. The crew used long-handled spanners for this, whereas today, the design would almost certainly incorporate a hydraulic system, to reduce the required time.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM THE RAILWAY MAGAZINEView All

From Upminster To Upcycled: Vivarail's D-train

Ben Jones visits Long Marston to find out how redundant District Line trains are being rebuilt to provide cheaper and greener alternatives to brand new multiple units – and how Vivarail is looking to the future with new methods of propulsion.

7 mins read
The Railway Magazine
February 2018

Thameslink Franchise Not Delivering Value For Money

AN IN-DEPTH report by the National Audit Office (NAO) into the Thameslink, Southern and Great Northern (TSGN) rail franchise has revealed it has not delivered value for money as a result of high levels of passenger disruption.

3 mins read
The Railway Magazine
February 2018

Ro-railers Ahead Of Their Time Or Overtaken By Events?

A new type of vehicle for use on both road and rail was trialled in the early 1930s, but never caught on. Alan Dale considers whether early road-rail vehicles were too advanced for their time.

8 mins read
The Railway Magazine
February 2018

Count Down Getting Farringdon Ready For The Elizabeth Line

The first tunnel section of the Elizabeth Line – better known as Crossrail – is due to open next December between Paddington and Abbey Wood via Canary Wharf. Keith Fender has been given an exclusive tour of Farringdon, one of the major interchange points on the £16billion project

5 mins read
The Railway Magazine
February 2018

Tyseley Launches £3million Share Offer For New TOC

FROM the moment Tyseley unveiled its newly overhauled flagship locomotive No. 7029 Clun Castle at the end of October, fans of the Collett 4-6-0 began to ask when the famous BR(W) ‘Castle’will double-head with sister No. 5043 Earl of Mount Edgcumbe on the main line.

4 mins read
The Railway Magazine
January 2018

RAIB Report Outlines Croydon Tram Operator's Safety Failings

THE crash of tram No. 2551 on a bend at Sandilands, Croydon on November 9, 2016 was, in all probability, caused by the driver suffering a micro-sleep during a 49-second period when the tram was passing through three consecutive tunnels in the hours of darkness.

2 mins read
The Railway Magazine
January 2018

Bredgar's Little Gem

Gareth Evans visits the Bredgar & Wormshill Railway to discover the latest developments at the 2ft-gauge line in Kent, run by a group of friends, and open once a month to the public. 

10+ mins read
The Railway Magazine
January 2018

East Coast Bailout Row Overshadows Minister Grayling's 'New Vision For Rail'

SECRETARY of State for Transport Chris Grayling has unveiled his vision for the evolution of passenger rail franchising in the UK.

3 mins read
The Railway Magazine
January 2018

A Narrow Gauge Railway Under South London

Keith Fender reports on the construction of the Northern Line extension to Battersea, which has necessitated the construction of a narrow gauge railway under south London – albeit a temporary one.

6 mins read
The Railway Magazine
January 2018

Five To Bid For £2.75bn Hs2 Train Contract

Five To Bid For £2.75bn Hs2 Train Contract

2 mins read
The Railway Magazine
December 2017
RELATED STORIES

TORI TOO POOR TO DUMP DEAN!

HARD-UP Tori Spelling’s marriage to Dean McDermott seems to be hanging by a thread — but an insider says she’s too broke to pull the plug!

1 min read
Globe
April 19, 2021

GRAVE CONCERNS FOR BURT'S LADIES

Fears Sally & Loni will square off at memorial service

2 mins read
Globe
April 19, 2021

EXTRAORDINARY BOATS

HELEN FRETTER ON JZERRO

6 mins read
Yachting World
April 2021

BURGLAR STEALS THE KITTY – BUT LEAVES A CAT!

A CAT burglar who raided the kitty at an Oregon restaurant fled on foot, but left a key clue behind — his personal pet feline, according to cops!

1 min read
Globe
April 19, 2021

SCOTTISH SOUNDINGS

A SPONTANEOUS CRUISE ALONG SCOTLAND’S WILD WEST COAST PROVED TO BE A VOYAGE OF SURPRISES FOR PHIL JOHNSON

10+ mins read
Yachting World
April 2021

FEARS AS 98-LB. DOLLY PARTON WASTES AWAY!

DOLLY PARTON’S latest yo-yo diet has turned into a disaster, say sources who are terrified the chesty 75-year-old country queen has shrunk to a scary skinny 98 pounds!

2 mins read
Globe
April 19, 2021

LONG LIVE THE KING

JEAN LE CAM WAS ALREADY A LEGEND, NOW HE’S THE UNDISPUTED HERO OF THE VENDÉE GLOBE, WRITES ED GORMAN

8 mins read
Yachting World
April 2021

KENYA FINDS DREW HARD TO STOMACH

CATTY Kenya Moore was chewing the fat about Real Housewives of Atlanta castmate Drew Sidora and tweeted, “She needs to pay for a tummy tuck!”

1 min read
Globe
April 19, 2021

SPECIAL REPORT

SAM FORTESCUE ON SELF-SAILING TECHNOLOGY

7 mins read
Yachting World
April 2021

BLOOD MONEY!

Fiend accused in dad’s murder busted for looting $134G family cash

1 min read
Globe
April 19, 2021