LEFT FIELD
evo India|February 2021
The Kia Sonet and the Mahindra Thar are selling like hotcakes. Which one of these two vastly different SUVs should you buy?
AATISH MISHRA

LINING THESE TWO UP SIDE BY SIDE WAS DOWNRIGHT ridiculous. They couldn’t be more at odds with each other — the Mahindra Thar with decades of legacy and heritage, elbowing its way in to the 21st century. Meanwhile, the Kia Sonet is at the bleeding edge of India’s obsession with ‘more for less,’ cramming everything from Bose speakers to a sunroof and ventilated seats into its tiny footprint. At first glance, there seems to be little in common with them save for the fact that they both roll down the road on four wheels. But look closer, and you will start drawing parallels. They’re both under four metres in length. They sit in a similar price bracket. They have got massive waiting periods. That last bit is crucial — both the Thar and the Sonet have managed to command attention from the market like few other cars have in the last year. Spec to spec, there’s no comparing them but plenty of people walking into Kia showrooms have the modernised Thar on their shortlist. And the other way around. It’s a head or heart decision on the face of it, but being the dedicated journalists that we are, we brought them both together to investigate.

The Sonet has been built on a formula that I am a little too familiar with. There’s been an onslaught of compact SUVs of late, and every time a new one is launched, we dutifully drive the whole lot together to see if the goal posts have been moved forward. The last one to make any real headway was the Sonet, inching ahead of its cousin, the Hyundai Venue. So it stands here today, repping the compact SUV segment against a challenger that is unperturbed by the obsessions of said segment. Fancy features? The Thar just shrugs and engages 4WD. Nevertheless, the Thar is doing enough to break into the mainstream — a factory-fitted hard top, a modern turbo-petrol, automatic transmissions, forward-facing rear seats, CarPlay — it’s almost like it wants to compete with this lot. Now is a good time to mention that in the company of the Thar, you might want to take the Sonet’s ‘SUV’ tag with a pinch of salt.

You have to break it down to the absolute fundamentals with these two. Take something as simple as getting in. With the Sonet, it is muscle memory. Open door, one leg in, plonk butt, other leg in, close door. The seat isn’t too high or too low — it’s just right. Sure, the guys at the back have to deal with a small door aperture — one of the many casualties of the short wheelbase — but one look at the Thar and they’ll be thankful they’re getting doors at all. Speaking of the Thar, you don’t get into it as much as you climb in. The first time may involve some uncomfortable calisthenics as you hoist yourself into the cabin, but you should figure out a semi-graceful manoeuvre soon enough. The same can’t be said about getting into the back — every attempt is a reminder of why you should’ve signed up for that yoga class. But once there, space is actually generous and you may not even mind the fact that the windows don’t roll down. This new Thar covers massive ground from where it used to be — it is way more convenient than it has ever been in the past, and yet the Sonet remains easier to live with.

Continue reading your story on the app

Continue reading your story in the magazine

MORE STORIES FROM EVO INDIAView All

“Stellantis is a huge opportunity for PSA and FCA”

Speaking to Citroen India’s Senior VPs Roland Bouchara (SVP sales and marketing) Eric Apode (SVP) and Saurabh Vatsa (Sr director, marketing) on the C5 Aircross, dealership ramp-up, the C-Cubed program and synergies with FCA

5 mins read
evo India
March 2021

McLAREN V2.0

McLaren’s first decade was a whirlwind of super and hypercars, highs and lows, and endless special editions. Now the Artura’s here to start the next chapter

10 mins read
evo India
March 2021

Citroen C5 Aircross

Citroen kicks off its Indian innings with its Compass and Tucson rival

9 mins read
evo India
March 2021

Meet the new boss

The 992-gen GT3 eschews big power gains for improvements where it really matters. Here’s everything you need to know

6 mins read
evo India
March 2021

TANGERINE SCREAM

As the first of AMG’s GT Black Series lands on Indian shores, we hit a near-freezing track for one wild ride

10+ mins read
evo India
March 2021

BIJOY KUMAR Y

Aren’t electric cars worthy of a ‘clean-slate’ design approach?

3 mins read
evo India
March 2021

Mahindra XUV300 Petrol AutoShift

Mahindra marries an AMT to the XUV300’s turbo-petrol engine and it isn’t a match made in heaven

2 mins read
evo India
March 2021

CZECH MATE

With styling tweaks, optional accessories and minor under-the-skin upgrades, the 2021 Jawa 42 gets a whole lot better

3 mins read
evo India
March 2021

50 PER CENT OF WHAT WE LAUNCH THIS YEAR WILL BE AMGS

Talking to Mercedes-Benz India’s VP of sales and marketing Santosh Iyer on AMG’s plans for 2021

4 mins read
evo India
March 2021

BMW 8 Series Gran Coupe

BMW’s four-door coupe is like Dr Banner when you want to chill, but packs a Hulk-sized punch when you don’t

8 mins read
evo India
March 2021
RELATED STORIES

OFF-ROAD RELIABLE

THE ROXOR IS THE BACKCOUNTRY BUG-OUT VEHICLE THAT CAN HANDLE THE JOB.

7 mins read
American Survival Guide
August 2020

MoD signs contract with MDSL to supply Light Specialist Vehicles to Indian Army

Providing further boost to ‘Make in India’, Ministry of Defence (MoD) signed a contract with Mahindra Defence Systems Ltd (MDSL) for supply of 1,300 Light Specialist Vehicles to the Indian Army, at a cost of Rs 1,056 crore, in New Delhi on March 22, 2021. The induction of vehicles is planned to be completed in four years.

1 min read
Aviation Update
April 2021

COLD NIGHTS AND NEW FRIENDS FROM NATURE'S FURY TO HER WARMTH

“Vimal, only a few seats are available, and I am going ahead and blocking two” I remember my wife saying something on these lines.

2 mins read
Smart Photography
April 2021

Mahindra's New Arsenal Spotted

Two big launches from Mahindra over the next year are going to be the new generation XUV500 and Scorpio. We spotted the near production ready mules on the road. Rahul Ghosh gives you all the details

3 mins read
Auto Today
April 2021

कम आधार से मार्च में कारों की बिक्री को धार

मार्च में वाहन कंपनियों ने बिक्री में 100 प्रतिशत से भी अधिक इजाफा दर्ज किया है। हालांकि पिछले वर्ष के न्यून आधार प्रभाव की वजह से आंकड़ों में इतनी तेजी दिख रही है। हालांकि वाहन उद्योग के लोगों का कहना है कि बिक्री के आंकड़ों को पिछले वर्ष मार्च में दर्ज बिक्री के संदर्भ में देखा जाना चाहिए जब लॉकडाउन की वजह से सात दिनों तक कोई बिक्री नहीं हो पाई थी।

1 min read
Business Standard - Hindi
April 02, 2021

Flipkart to Deploy over 25,000 Electric Vehicles by 2030

Flipkart has announced its plans for deploying more than 25,000 electric vehicles (EVs) by 2030, an initiative to change its logistic fleet to green energy vehicles.

1 min read
UNIQUE TIMES
March - April 2021

Amazon India chooses Mahindra Electric as partner to help fulfil e-mobility goals

E-Commerce giant’s delivery fleet of 10,000 EVs by 2025 to be designed and manufactured by OEMs in India

3 mins read
MOTORINDIA
March 2021

India Auto Show 2021 Exhibitors and visitors welcome the return of auto trade fairs

With India Auto Show 2021, a prime automotive event, returning to Mumbai, automobile enthusiasts, vehicle manufacturers and dealers marked their enthusiastic presence with new products and solutions, reports Rajesh Rajgor

4 mins read
MOTORINDIA
March 2021

‘ADAPTING TO CHANGES QUICKLY IS THE KEY TO GROWTH'

ABHISHEK CHANDA, Co-Founder of Kalasha Fine Jewels, Hyderabad, says hard work and transparency are his two success mantras

2 mins read
The Retail Jeweller
January - February 2021

TRUE LEISURE

WITH OCCUPANCY RATES REACHING PRE-COVID LEVELS OF OVER 84%, KAVINDER SINGH MAINTAINS THAT INDIA HOLIDAYS AT CLUB MAHINDRA RESORTS

7 mins read
Hotelier India
March 2021