Poging GOUD - Vrij
Free speech for all! (Except Bob Vylan)
The Observer
|July 06, 2025
In October 1989, the Muslim Institute helped organise a meeting on the Salman Rushdie affair at Manchester town hall.
It had been eight months since Iran's Ayatollah Khomeini had imposed his fatwa calling for the killing of Rushdie for his “blasphemous” novel The Satanic Verses, forcing the writer into hiding for a decade.
On the platform was the institute’s founder, Kalim Siddiqui, an enthusiastic supporter of Iranian theocracy. The fatwa, he told the audience, was just, and Rushdie had to die. Who in the audience agreed, he asked. Most raised their hands. How many, he continued, would be willing personally to kill Rushdie. Most kept their hands up. It was an electrifying, terrifying moment, caught by TV cameras, replayed on the evening news and discussed in parliament.
The International Committee for the Defence of Salman Rushdie, formed after the fatwa, debated whether to press the authorities to charge Siddiqui with incitement to murder or to launch a private prosecution themselves. The chair of the committee, Frances D’Souza, opposed any such move. Neither Siddiqui nor his followers, she told me years later, had been “in any position to carry out the fatwa ... They had no weapons, no knowledge of Salman’s whereabouts and no immediate intention of carrying out their threats. Therefore, using the US court ruling on incitement, there was no ‘clear and present danger’ of Siddiqui’s words becoming action.” The committee agreed and decided not to pursue any prosecution.
Today, that decision might seem astonishing. Attitudes to incitement have transformed over the past four decades. The threshold for deciding what constitutes incitement has become lower. And perceptions of incitement have become, even
Dit verhaal komt uit de July 06, 2025-editie van The Observer.
Abonneer u op Magzter GOLD voor toegang tot duizenden zorgvuldig samengestelde premiumverhalen en meer dan 9000 tijdschriften en kranten.
Bent u al abonnee? Aanmelden
MEER VERHALEN VAN The Observer
The Observer
Lion's mane jellyfish
Brandy! Brandy! Oil, opium, morphia! Anything to ease this infernal agony! Seems a bit over the top to me, but that's fiction for you (see The Adventure of the Lion's Mane by Conan Doyle).
2 mins
September 21, 2025

The Observer
The United Nations is on its knees, but still breathing and still liberal
From Gaza to Trump, the challenges mount. But ahead of its general assembly this week, the organisation remains the last hope for many people across the world
6 mins
September 21, 2025
The Observer
In a digital world, the use of outdated stats simply doesn't add up
Our economy gauges were invented in the last century. We need a system that works now, writes Zachary Karabell
3 mins
September 21, 2025
The Observer
UK to build 12 nuclear plants in £10bn plan
The announcement last week that a dozen new nuclear power stations are to be built in Hartlepool is unlike anything else that has been attempted in the UK.
2 mins
September 21, 2025

The Observer
Heated debate: why Churchill's birthplace lies at the heart of UK solar battle
Row over plans to build 2 million panels on land around historic Blenheim Palace has become symbolic of a national struggle. Architecture critic Rowan Moore reports
8 mins
September 21, 2025
The Observer
Trump's assault on the media goes into overdrive
Donald Trump has warned that media outlets that are \"against\" him could be punished as his administration's crackdown on opponents intensifies after the assassination of Charlie Kirk, raising fears for freedom of speech in America.
3 mins
September 21, 2025
The Observer
Digital ID, two-child cap, taxes... Starmer on front foot to save his leadership
The prime minister’s supporters say he’s got the message and will mount a spirited defence at party conference. For others it’s too little, too late, writes Rachel Sylvester
4 mins
September 21, 2025

The Observer
Liberal Hollywood shuffles into a dark night after elegiac Emmys
Can awards shows tell us anything about the state of a nation? Attending the 2025 Emmys last Sunday, there were times when it felt like the answer was an unequivocal: hell yes.
4 mins
September 21, 2025

The Observer
One village, one week in the war for the West Bank
What began with an attack by settlers led to the death of a teenager and ended with a brutal IDF siege. As the UK prepares to recognise Palestinian statehood, Isabel Coles' report from al-Mughayyir shows why it may never be attained
11 mins
September 21, 2025

The Observer
FakeX - criminals hijack interest in Musk's company to defraud investors
Online fraudsters are stealing the identities of investment firms to con millions out of people wanting a slice of Elon Musk's space unicorn.
5 mins
September 21, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size