Facebook Pixel A PERSISTING CONFUSION OVER IDENTITY | The Morning Standard - newspaper - Lees dit verhaal op Magzter.com

Poging GOUD - Vrij

A PERSISTING CONFUSION OVER IDENTITY

The Morning Standard

|

July 08, 2024

A recent comment has brought up an old question: who gets to decide religious identity? It's tougher to answer in a land where harmony is stressed over uniformity

- BALBIR PUNJ

A PERSISTING CONFUSION OVER IDENTITY

WHILE speaking in the Lok Sabha on Monday (July 1), Rahul Gandhi said, "Aap Hindu ho hi nahin (You are not Hindu)." The line was directed at the BJP benches, including Prime Minister Narendra Modi, his cabinet colleagues, fellow members of the House and, by extension, the millions of voters who supported the saffron outfit.

Rahul's words indicated three thingshis sense of entitlement, ignorance of Indian ethos and disrespect for democratic norms.

Can Rahul or anybody else decide who is a Hindu? During the just-concluded Lok Sabha polls, 23.59 crore Indians voted for the BJP. There are likely to be millions more who support the BJP, but couldn't vote for their favourite party for various reasons. A majority of them identify themselves as Hindus. With one utterance, Rahul seemed to strip them of this identity.

Who can make such a statement? Only someone with an acute sense of entitlement. Unlike Abrahamic religions, Hinduism is timeless (hence also sanatan), catholic and pluralistic. There is no centralised authority in Hinduism, and none has any right to pass such edicts regarding the faith.

Identity can work differently for the Abrahamic faiths. For example, the Ahmadiyya sect in Pakistan has been 'shunned' from Islam, and its followers are routinely persecuted because their belief system differs a little from the mainline Shia-Sunni doctrines. These two sects are also perpetually locked in internecine wars because of their conflicting theological beliefs. Ironically, Ahmadiyyas were at the forefront, along with communists and the Muslim League, in striving for an independent Pakistan. Doesn't Rahul somewhat sound like a similar establishment voice when he decrees in Lok Sabha who is a Hindu and who isn't?

MEER VERHALEN VAN The Morning Standard

The Morning Standard

A Big Dream in Two Rooms

Triveni Kala Sangam turns 75 this year.

time to read

3 mins

March 11, 2026

The Morning Standard

The Morning Standard

Agentic AI replacing corporate depts: Xebia CEO

ARTIFICIAL intelligence systems capable of planning and executing complex tasks are beginning to replace entire corporate departments as companies move beyond experimentation and deploy \"agentic AI\" in real operations, Anand Sahay, global CEO at Xebia, told TNIE.

time to read

1 min

March 11, 2026

The Morning Standard

Delinking women's quota from delimitation explored

THE government is learnt to be exploring a possibility to implement the Women’s Reservation Act even before the completion of the post-Census delimitation exercise for Lok Sabha and Assembly constituencies.

time to read

1 mins

March 11, 2026

The Morning Standard

Only UCC can ensure equal rights to women: SC

THE only way to ensure equal rights to all women in the country is to bring in the Uniform Civil Code (UCC), the Supreme Court said on Tuesday.

time to read

1 min

March 11, 2026

The Morning Standard

The Morning Standard

Don't raze house of Holi clash accused: HC to MCD

Haze and low visibility blinds Capital

time to read

1 mins

March 11, 2026

The Morning Standard

US readies 'most intense strikes', Iran hits residential building in Bahrain

Officials in Iran say ‘not looking for truce’, threaten to eliminate Trump

time to read

2 mins

March 11, 2026

The Morning Standard

Union Cabinet eases FDI norms for China, neighbours with land border

The Cabinet has also introduced an expedited approval mechanism, under which investment proposals from such countries in specified manufacturing sectors will be processed within 60 days. The fast-track window will initially apply to capital goods, electronic capital goods, electronic components, and polysilicon and ingot-wafer sectors. In these cases, the investee company must remain majority-owned and controlled by resident Indian citizens.

time to read

1 min

March 11, 2026

The Morning Standard

The Morning Standard

Pinarayi reaches out to Pentecostal churches in Kerala

IN a politically significant decision aimed at making inroads into various Christian denominations ahead of the assembly elections, the state government on Tuesday decided to recognise Pentecostalism as a Christian sub-sect.

time to read

1 min

March 11, 2026

The Morning Standard

The Morning Standard

Eyes on IPL amid West Asia conflict

With season set to start on Mar 28, BCCI may have to take a call if the ongoing situation escalates in coming weeks

time to read

2 mins

March 11, 2026

The Morning Standard

Naidu asks officials to develop AP as an Integrated Strategic Material Hub

CM N Chandrababu Naidu has directed officials to develop Andhra Pradesh as an Integrated Strategic Material Hub.

time to read

1 min

March 11, 2026

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size