'A shattering experience' Apology at last for white and Indigenous men who were swapped at birth
The Guardian
|March 22, 2024
For nearly seven decades, two Canadian men lived lives meant for the other. Richard Beauvais, 68, believed was Indigenous. Eddy Ambrose, who shares the same birthday, always understood that he was of Ukrainian descent.
But that reality shattered four years ago when, after a series of DNA tests, they learned they had been mistakenly switched at birth.
Yesterday, Wab Kinew, the recently elected premier of Manitoba, was due to apologise to Beauvais and Ambrose in the province's legislature, reversing a decision by the previous government to deny responsibility for the mix-up.
The painful saga, which embodies the damaging effects of Canada's colonial policies, also highlights the fragile nature of identity and the complex meaning of family.
"To have the core understanding of who you are - and who your parents and siblings were - taken away from you is a shattering experience," said Bill Gange, the lawyer representing both men. "I don't think either man knows what it will fully mean for them down the line, but hopefully it will help."
Since the shocking revelation of their true identities, the two men have traced the fateful 1955 mix-up to the Arborg Medical Nursing Unit, then a newly opened rural hospital in southern Manitoba where staff gave families the wrong baby.
Ambrose, born to a Cree mother and French father, would spend his youth in the farming community of Rembrandt, oblivious to his Métis roots. The parents who raised him taught him Ukrainian folk songs.
They died when he was young and he was cared for by relatives until he was placed in foster care with a family he came to love immensely.
Dit verhaal komt uit de March 22, 2024-editie van The Guardian.
Abonneer u op Magzter GOLD voor toegang tot duizenden zorgvuldig samengestelde premiumverhalen en meer dan 9000 tijdschriften en kranten.
Bent u al abonnee? Aanmelden
MEER VERHALEN VAN The Guardian
The Guardian
BP announces its first female CEO as Auchincloss quits after just two years
BP's board has appointed its first female chief executive in a move to revive the oil company's fortunes, after ousting Murray Auchincloss less than two years into his role.
2 mins
December 19, 2025
The Guardian
Government denies trying to break jailed pro-Palestine activists
The government is “not trying to break the bodies” of Palestine Action protesters on hunger strike, a minister has insisted, after a doctor said eight of the activists are dying.
1 mins
December 19, 2025
The Guardian
England's hopes melt away in sun as Cummins glows with authority
Tourists teetering 158 behind after Australia captain leads fine bowling display by hosts
4 mins
December 19, 2025
The Guardian
EU leaders race to reach deal on funding Ukraine
European Union leaders are racing to secure a funding deal for Ukraine that has been cast as a choice between “money today or blood tomorrow”, as Belgium comes under rising pressure over its opposition to a loan secured against Russia's frozen assets.
3 mins
December 19, 2025
The Guardian
New Epstein photos show quotes from Lolita written on women
Images released before deadline for Department of Justice to publish files
3 mins
December 19, 2025
The Guardian
Rayner memoir fuels leadership speculation
Angela Rayner is writing a memoir about her rise to become deputy prime minister and her subsequent fall from grace, the Guardian can confirm, in a move that will be seen as an attempt to set the narrative before any leadership contest.
3 mins
December 19, 2025
The Guardian
Lyon’s wait for golden wickets is finally over
Going second on Australia’s all-time list, the off-spinner kept his cool on return as temperatures soared
3 mins
December 19, 2025
The Guardian
Bank of England cuts interest rates to 3.75% in boost for economy
The Bank of England has cut interest rates by a quarter point, giving a pre-Christmas boost to the struggling UK economy, but a split vote among its rate setters pointed to continued concerns about inflation.
3 mins
December 19, 2025
The Guardian
China introduces condom tax as it tries to boost birthrate
China is set to impose a value-added tax (VAT) on condoms and other contraceptives for the first time in three decades, as the country tries to boost its birthrate and modernise tax laws.
2 mins
December 19, 2025
The Guardian
Kenyan vet Munyua bites back to neuter De Decker
The Kenyan debutant David Munyua created one of the biggest shocks in the history of the PDC World Darts Championship by beating the 18th seed, Mike De Decker.
1 mins
December 19, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size

