Poging GOUD - Vrij
Ambiguous Al crash report did what it shouldn't—leave much to imagination
Hindustan Times Haryana
|July 18, 2025
As the hour struck midnight on Friday, July 12 —just in time to meet the globally prescribed deadline—the Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau released a loosely worded and unsigned preliminary report examining the AI-171 crash of June 12 that killed 260 people, including 12 crew members.

Social media and the internet exploded with further speculation, with many arguing the much-awaited report invited more questions than answers. Now, with The Wall Street Journal reporting that the captain cut off fuel supply to the switches, citing anonymous sources familiar with the evidence, there are even more questions.
Clearing some air
Aviation industry executives pointed out that the preliminary report did clear the air to an extent, ruling out several initial theories. The possibility of a bird strike leading to dual-engine malfunction was eliminated. The report also rules out pilot fatigue, arguing both pilots had adequate rest. Wind shear, weather and aircraft weight problems also appear ruled out.
Questions were previously raised about aircraft flaps remaining retracted and incorrectly set for takeoff, but experts say this might have been a consequence of dual engine failure. The aircraft's landing gear also remained deployed throughout the short flight, while on a 787, wheels are normally withdrawn immediately after takeoff.
The report states that fuel loss led to engine malfunctions, caused by fuel control levers "transitioning" from run to cutoff position within one second of each other. This is clearly the main cause since both engines lost power once fuel supply was cut. The report is silent on how this happened, although it paraphrases an interaction between pilots to suggest manual error may have been responsible. The WSJ report now identifies the captain as the person who allegedly cut off fuel. India's aviation regulator is yet to respond.
When each second counts
Even after the preliminary report became public, a theory gained ground that the crash might have been deliberate pilot suicide, of which there have been more cases than most readers would be aware. But senior commanders and experts point to important lacunae with this theory.
Dit verhaal komt uit de July 18, 2025-editie van Hindustan Times Haryana.
Abonneer u op Magzter GOLD voor toegang tot duizenden zorgvuldig samengestelde premiumverhalen en meer dan 9000 tijdschriften en kranten.
Bent u al abonnee? Aanmelden
MEER VERHALEN VAN Hindustan Times Haryana
Hindustan Times Haryana
SA crush Pak by 150 runs in game affected by rain
South Africa steamrolled Pakistan by 150 runs in a rain-affected round-robin league match to leapfrog to the top of the points table in the Women’s World Cup here on Tuesday.
1 mins
October 22, 2025
Hindustan Times Haryana
India need to course correct for ODI World Cup in South Africa
Batting woes in the Perth ODI versus Australia shows India have plenty to sort for the 2027 tournament
3 mins
October 22, 2025
Hindustan Times Haryana
Small stores slow to pass on GST rate cuts
It has been nearly a month since the government's latest Goods and Services Tax (GST) rate cuts came into effect, but chances are some packaged goods may still be sold at old prices in small retail stores.
2 mins
October 22, 2025
Hindustan Times Haryana
Trade to trust: Rebuilding Canada-India partnership
Canadian foreign minister Anita Anand’s visit to Delhi and Mumbai last week marks a new juncture in Canada-India relations.
3 mins
October 22, 2025
Hindustan Times Haryana
Expanding net: MCD plans 30 new border toll plazas
The Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) plans to hire a new agency to collect toll tax at 156 entry points on Delhi's borders —30 more than in 2021, when 124 sites were covered.
1 mins
October 22, 2025
Hindustan Times Haryana
AIR INDIA FLIGHT SAFETY AUDITOR FOUND DEAD IN GGM PG: POLICE
A flight safety auditor with Air India was found dead in his room at a paying guest (PG) accommodation in Gurugram on Monday, police said on Tuesday.
1 min
October 22, 2025
Hindustan Times Haryana
Burden of proof: SC warns against rigidity
Rule relating to prosecution’s burden of proof benefits serious offenders, the court noted
2 mins
October 22, 2025
Hindustan Times Haryana
Adaptation to be key issue at COP30: UN climate chief
Adaptation will be a central issue at the 2025 UN Climate Change Conference (COP30) in Brazil's Belem, with parties expected to agree on adaptation indicators and work to close the adaptation finance gap, UN Climate Chief Simon Stiell said on Tuesday.
1 min
October 22, 2025
Hindustan Times Haryana
Indian, Chinese soldiers exchange Diwali sweets
Indian and Chinese soldiers exchanged sweets on Diwali as a goodwill gesture along the line of actual control (LAC) that stretches from Ladakh to Sikkim and Arunachal Pradesh, officials said on Tuesday.
1 min
October 22, 2025
Hindustan Times Haryana
Opposition condemns Lokpal tender to buy 7 luxury cars worth ₹5cr
ON OCT 16, LOKPAL FLOATED A TENDER TO PROCURE SEVEN BMW CARS TO PROVIDE A VEHICLE FOR EACH MEMBER OF THE OMBUDSMAN
1 mins
October 22, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size