Prøve GULL - Gratis

'Legally correct but rather unfair'

The Philippine Star

|

July 27, 2025

Ex-justices, legal experts weigh in on SC ruling

- JANVIC MATEO and ELIZABETH MARCELO

While it may be legally correct, the Supreme Court (SC) decision on the impeachment case against Vice President Sara Duterte is "rather unfair," former SC associate justice Adolfo Azcuna said.

In a statement yesterday posted on Facebook, Azcuna said the High Court's decision gave a "new definition" to what constitutes the initiation of an impeachment complaint.

"Recall that in the Davide case, the Supreme Court defined initiating an impeachment complaint as putting it in the order of business and referring it to a proper committee. This was not done to the three earlier complaints in this case," he said.

"The new definition, however, would now cover a situation where the complaints were not referred to a committee and, after the lapse of the time to do so, archived, and thus, the Supreme Court said, 'effectively dismissed,' Azcuna added.

He noted that the House of Representatives relied on the prevailing definition at the time, which was also based on a previous SC decision.

The lower chamber archived the first three complaints against Duterte and instead decided on a fourth complaint.

For Azcuna, it would be unfair to apply the new definition on the complaint "as it was precisely adopted in reliance on the Supreme Court's then prevailing definition." He urged the High Court to issue a supplemental resolution and apply the Doctrine of Operative Facts, wherein "the action and things done will be treated as valid, and the new definition will be applied prospectively, i.e. to future cases." "In this way, I respectfully submit, the people's unwavering demand for accountability now will be served, and the trial in the Senate can still, and finally, proceed forthwith," he added.

FLERE HISTORIER FRA The Philippine Star

The Philippine Star

Waste of people’s money

The President has just certified as urgent the abolition of the travel tax, a move I consider wise.

time to read

4 mins

February 14, 2026

The Philippine Star

DHSUD @ 7: Bringing hope, changing lives

Seven years on, DHSUD highlights reforms and housing programs that are expanding access to safe, affordable homes for Filipino families.

time to read

2 mins

February 14, 2026

The Philippine Star

6,045 voters register for BARMM polls

Up to 6,045 voters have filed applications in the first four days of the voter registration for the first parliamentary elections in the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (BARMM).

time to read

1 min

February 14, 2026

The Philippine Star

Word war rages between Chinese embassy, lawmakers

There appears to be no ceasefire in sight between lawmakers and the Chinese embassy, with both trading barbs before the weekend over the recent Senate resolution condemning Chinese diplomats for making hostile remarks against Philippine officials.

time to read

4 mins

February 14, 2026

The Philippine Star

The Philippine Star

DHSUD accelerates housing delivery as Expanded 4PH gains ground in 2026

Policy reforms, new housing modalities, and stronger public-private partnerships mark a fast start to the year.

time to read

4 mins

February 14, 2026

The Philippine Star

Student falls from DLSU building

The De La Salle University confirmed that a student fell one floor from a DLSU building yesterday.

time to read

1 min

February 14, 2026

The Philippine Star

Castro hits Sara, warns vs 2028 Manchurian puppet

Presidential Communications Undersecretary Claire Castro yesterday hit back at Vice President Sara Duterte, saying it is possible that the Philippines would no longer be a country by 2028 if Filipinos elect a Manchurian candidate.

time to read

3 mins

February 14, 2026

The Philippine Star

27% of Pinoys experienced or saw cheating in relationships

One in four Filipinos either personally experienced or witnessed some form of cheating in relationships, according to a survey conducted by Social Weather Stations (SWS).

time to read

1 min

February 14, 2026

The Philippine Star

The Philippine Star

Japan seizes China fishing boat, arrests captain

Japan seized a Chinese fishing boat and arrested its skipper, authorities said Friday, an incident that could deepen a spat between the Asian giants.

time to read

2 mins

February 14, 2026

The Philippine Star

SC to ombudsman, ICI: Comment on Zaldy petition

The Supreme Court (SC) has ordered Ombudsman Jesus Crispin Remulla and the Independent Commission for Infrastructure (ICI) to justify their findings that linked former Ako Bicol party-list congressman and fugitive Elizaldy Co to an anomalous flood control project in Oriental Mindoro.

time to read

1 min

February 14, 2026

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size