Prøve GULL - Gratis
COMEDY, FREE SPEECH, AND THE LAW
The New Indian Express Vellore
|September 01, 2025
The quality of the content offered by influencers of our time might often be questionable. Yet, it is one thing to acknowledge this issue, and quite another to call for a law to 'set it right'
It's the prerogative of the legislature to make laws or not. Law is not a solution for every unethical act in human conduct, which would need a social or cultural diagnosis and appropriate remedies. For example, one is not punished for ingratitude, for it is only a moral wrong and not a penal offense. If a person tells a lie to their spouse, unless it contains penal ingredients, they are not punished. Bad Samaritans cannot be prosecuted for being bad. Such instances of moral wrongs are numerous in human life.
When it comes to freedom of speech and expression, legislation is a more serious business. Free speech is a constitutional guarantee under Article 19(1)(a). This can only be subjected to reasonable restrictions as indicated in Article 19(2) of the Constitution. Whether a law restrictive of free speech is reasonable or not is for the constitutional court to decide. Given the scheme of things, the court asking other branches of the state to enact restrictive legislation is bound to be inherently problematic. It negates Montesquieu's age-old idea of the separation of powers.
The Supreme Court called for a law on digital content when YouTuber Ranveer Allahbadia challenged the multiple cases against him in different parts of the country. The court's demand for restrictive laws renders the constitutional scheme under Article 19 nugatory, as this writer has previously noted in an earlier piece (TNIE, March 12, 2025).
Denne historien er fra September 01, 2025-utgaven av The New Indian Express Vellore.
Abonner på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av kuraterte premiumhistorier og over 9000 magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent? Logg på
FLERE HISTORIER FRA The New Indian Express Vellore
The New Indian Express Vellore
A RIVER REMEMBERS: MEANDERING MEMORY OF WATER
BENEATH the calm surface of a river lies an ancient intelligence — one that remembers every bend, flood, and wandering path it has ever carved through the Earth.
2 mins
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Vellore
10 months on, NMC yet to act against 30 docs for 'sponsored' foreign trips
THE National Medical Commission (NMC) is yet to take any action against 30 doctors who accepted free trips to Monaco and Paris worth ₹1.91 crore last year, despite the Department of Pharmaceuticals (DoP) recommendations that action should be taken against them for violating professional misconduct.
1 mins
October 22, 2025

The New Indian Express Vellore
FIR against former Punjab DGP, ex-minister wife over son’s death
FORMER Punjab DGP Mohammad Mustafa, his wife and former minister Razia Sultana, along with their daughter and daughter-in-law, have been booked for murder and criminal conspiracy by Haryana Police in connection with the death of their 35-year-old son, Agil Akhter.
1 mins
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Vellore
At least 30 rebels give NDA, Oppn a headache
REBEL and independent candidates may spin the poll arithmetic for both the ruling NDA and the Opposition Mahagathbandhan in the Bihar Assembly elections, scheduled in two phases on November 6 and 11.
1 min
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Vellore
Applications invited under TN’s Breadwinner Scheme
THE school education department has allocated ₹11.17 crore for the Breadwinner Scheme, under which financial assistance of ₹50,000 to ₹75,000 is provided to students whose earning parent has either passed away or become disabled in an accident.
1 min
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Vellore
Winter blackouts loom as Russia targets Kyiv’s grids
AS the lights went out in her hometown, 40-year-old Zinaida Kot could not help but think about her next dialysis treatment for kidney disease. Without electricity, the machine that keeps her alive stops working.
1 min
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Vellore
Adding caution to traffic lights
GARRETT MORGAN
1 mins
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Vellore
Two dons-turned-politicians draw battle lines on Mokama poll turf
BATTLE lines have been drawn in Bihar’s Mokama assembly constituency ahead of the first-phase polls on November 6, as two don-turned-politicians, Anant Singh and Surajbhan Singh, prepare for a high-octane electoral clash.
2 mins
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Vellore
Speaker appoints lawyer to assist panel probing Justice Varma graft case
LOK Sabha Speaker Om Birla has appointed advocate Karan Umesh Salvi as a consultant to assist the judges’ inquiry committee investigating allegations of corruption against Justice Yashwant Varma.
1 min
October 22, 2025
The New Indian Express Vellore
7 Punjab youths duped in Kazakhstan, appeal for help
SEVEN young men from Punjab’s Ropar district are stranded in Kazakhstan after a local travel agent allegedly duped them by promising high-paying jobs as drivers.
1 mins
October 22, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size