Prøve GULL - Gratis
BALANCING THE INTERESTS OF STATE & JUSTICE SEEKERS
The Morning Standard
|November 25, 2024
In some contexts, the court under CJI Chandrachud's leadership fell short of expectations. There is no point in creating physical spaces and amenities without upholding the essence of justice

The soul of justice cannot be enclosed in world-class brick and mortar structures, just as the cause of liberty is not served by sermons in structured judgments. The constitutional protection for the right to privacy is not ensured by declaring it a fundamental right but by holding unconstitutional intrusive acts of the state through its enforcement agents. Upholding constitutional values is in the nature of a sacrament; any willful infraction or apparent insouciance in protecting those values makes the justice delivery system suspect in the eyes of the public.
Over a billion people in our country are watching how our courts attempt to balance the interests of the state with the interests of those seeking justice. For a polity as divisive as one prevailing since 2014, the constant vigil of the court is the only way to ensure our constitutional values are safe.
Chief Justice D Y Chandrachud's tenure was high on optics and somewhat low on delivery. The court under his stewardship often compromised even on liberty, of which he was ostensibly a champion. His majoritarian tilt, reflected in some of his judgments, was worrisome. At the heart of the justice delivery system is the ability of the court to stand up to the excesses of the executive; to speak truth to power. The court's record in that endeavor has been rather weak.
Denne historien er fra November 25, 2024-utgaven av The Morning Standard.
Abonner på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av kuraterte premiumhistorier og over 9000 magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent? Logg på
FLERE HISTORIER FRA The Morning Standard
The Morning Standard
Passenger on B’luru-Varanasi flight tries to enter cockpit
A passenger on an Air India Express flight (IX-1086) from Bengaluru to Varanasi on Monday attempted to enter the aircraft’s cockpit, claiming that he tried to open it by mistake as he isa first-time flyer and was looking for the toilet, sources said.
1 min
September 23, 2025
The Morning Standard
Salman, Aamir to appear in Kajol-Twinkle talk show
ALMAN Khan and Aamir Khan are set to be the first guests appearing on the upcoming Amazon Prime talk show, Two Much with Twinkle and Kajol.
1 min
September 23, 2025
The Morning Standard
Pannun aide & Khalistani terrorist detained, booked under arms act in Canada
KHALISTANI terrorist Inderjit Singh Gosal, a close aide of designated terrorist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun of the banned Sikhs for Justice (SFJ), has reportedly been arrested in Canada, intelligence sources have claimed.
1 min
September 23, 2025

The Morning Standard
Meet 15-year-old archer Gatha, who made waves at Archery World Championships
ON a humid evening in Gwangju, Korea on September 12, 15-year-old recurve archer Gatha Khadake was living her dream in the Archery World Championships.
2 mins
September 23, 2025
The Morning Standard
Suspense over Phytosaur fossil in Jaisalmer village
SUSPENSE and excitement continue to mount in Megha village in Fatehgarh subdivision of Jaisalmer district where ancient fossilised remains were recently unearthed near Harpal’s pond.
1 mins
September 23, 2025
The Morning Standard
Rahul, Kharge to attend CWC meeting in Patna on Sept 24
THE Congress will hold an extended meeting of its Working Committee (CWC) in Patna on September 24 as part of a show of strength and its bid to regain lost ground in Bihar since the 1990s. Party sources said the focus will be on Bihar, campaign strategy, future polls and alleged “vote chori.”
1 min
September 23, 2025

The Morning Standard
‘A deal will happen after Trump says done’
Mark Linscott, former Assistant US Trade Representative, talks about the persistent roarblocks for trade pact
3 mins
September 23, 2025
The Morning Standard
Will assess flood damage to paddy, maize: Govt
THE Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers’ Welfare will form a team to assess the extent of damages due to floods and rainfall caused to kharif crops, particularly paddy and maize.
1 mins
September 23, 2025
The Morning Standard
TN BJP chief meets Nadda amid alliance speculation
AMID speculation that the BJP may soon induct some former AIADMK leaders, Tamil Nadu BJP president Nainar Nagenthran met party national president JP Nadda in Delhi on Monday, accompanied by Union Minister Manohar Lal Khattar.
1 min
September 23, 2025
The Morning Standard
ED widens probe in illegal betting apps scam case
ROBIN Uthappa, ex-Indian cricket player, on Monday appeared before the Enforcement Directorate (ED) for questioning under provisions of the Prevention of Money laundering Act (PMLA) in connection with a probe linked to the controversial online betting platform 1xBet, officials said.
1 min
September 23, 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size