GNU Cabinet: Ministers' performance raises questions

AS THE Government of National Unity (GNU) marks its first year in office, opinions remain sharply divided on its performance. Some ministers have emerged as coalition-era stars, while others have floundered, raising questions about leadership, accountability, and the country’s economic prospects.

- HOPE NTANZI

Drawing from interviews, policy trackers, and expert analysis, Independent Media assess who delivered, and who were missing in action.

The GNU expanded its cabinet from 30 to 32 members, alongside an increase in deputy ministers from 36 to 43.

"By global standards, this represents a large executive," said political analyst Theo Neethling of the University of the Free State. However, Neethling highlighted that the coalition structure of the GNU was generally more acceptable to South Africans than a single-party government, formed in direct response to calls for greater cooperation to address pressing national challenges.

"The GNU, with its broader representation and diversity of voices, is more responsive and accountable to the public than previous cabinets, particularly compared to the era when state capture became a defining feature of governance," Neethling said.

According to Neethling, certain ministers had distinguished themselves through effective leadership and policy direction. He viewed Parks Tau as an "inspired choice" in the Trade, Industry and Competition portfolio, noting that this critical ministry benefits significantly from Tau’s leadership.

Ronald Lamola, though initially seen as inexperienced in foreign affairs, has nonetheless "performed commendably" in his role as Minister of International Affairs. Senzo Mchunu, previously recognised for his effectiveness in the Water and Sanitation portfolio, is regarded as a "considerable improvement" in his new role as Police Minister.

Enoch Godongwana is credited with showing "a steady hand at Treasury," and Kgosientsho Ramokgopa has competently managed the demanding Electricity and Energy portfolio.

Neethling added: "These are some of the most capable ANC ministers, who collectively hold over 60% of Cabinet positions."