Prøve GULL - Gratis
Indira's India & Modi's Bharat
Business Standard
|July 26, 2025
As Narendra Modi becomes India's second-longest consecutively serving Prime Minister, we look at how he compares with Indira Gandhi across four key dimensions
On the day that Narendra Modi won his third term in June 2024, it was inevitable that this year he would become India's second-longest serving Prime Minister in consecutive terms, surpassing Indira Gandhi (January 24, 1966 to March 24, 1977).
It also became inevitable, therefore, that around this time in 2025, the season of Modi vs Indira comparisons will begin. Let me be the first, or among the first, of the block.
First of all, we need to look at the larger political realities in which each came to power and the challenges to their authority. Then we will assess their record across four dimensions: Politics, strategic and foreign affairs, the economy, and nationalism.
Mrs Gandhi and Mr Modi took over in completely different circumstances. There was a differential in political capital between the two. Mrs Gandhi had not won an election in 1966. She was a convenient compromise after Lal Bahadur Shastri's death.
She didn't help her cause by looking overawed in Parliament early on, and Socialist Ram Manohar Lohia dismissed her as a "goongi gudiya" (a doll who didn't speak). She had also inherited a broken economy. The growth rate in 1965 was (-) 2.6 per cent, in fact. The triple blow of a war, droughts, food shortages and instability and the deaths of two prime ministers in harness within 19 months had weakened India.
The picture for Mr Modi in 2014 was the exact opposite. He won a majority, the first in India after 30 years, and was his party's chosen candidate; the economy was averaging a robust 6.5 per cent growth across the preceding 15 years. His was a peaceful, planned, predictable electoral transition. The degree of difficulty on his first day in power was way lower than Mrs Gandhi's, just as his political capital was enormously higher.
Denne historien er fra July 26, 2025-utgaven av Business Standard.
Abonner på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av kuraterte premiumhistorier og over 9000 magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent? Logg på
FLERE HISTORIER FRA Business Standard
Business Standard
Mkts up for 2nd day on IT gains
Stock markets closed higher for the second straight session on Tuesday, driven by gains in bank, IT, and capital goods shares.
1 min
February 18, 2026
Business Standard
Cooling hub Sri City gets a Carrier legacy stamp
Firm to invest ₹1,000 cr to set up AC mfg unit
2 mins
February 18, 2026
Business Standard
India, France forge ‘special global strategic partnership’
The facility will be operated by Tata Advanced Systems Limited, with Singh and his French counterpart in attendance.
2 mins
February 18, 2026
Business Standard
India a beacon of hope in uncertain times, says Modi
India is a stabilising force in a world marked by geopolitical churn and economic uncertainty, said Prime Minister Narendra Modi in a message to the Global Economic Cooperation (GEC) 2026 conference in Mumbai.
1 min
February 18, 2026
Business Standard
Air India, Lufthansa group plan joint biz agreement to deepen collaboration
Air India and the Lufthansa group plan to enter into a joint business agreement wherein the two sides will collaborate on multiple strategic areas, including coordinated route planning and flight schedules in specific markets.
1 mins
February 18, 2026
Business Standard
Warner Bros reopens talks as Paramount signals higher bid
Warner Bros Discovery has agreed to reopen negotiations with rival Hollywood studio Paramount Skydance after the suitor proposed raising its bid
2 mins
February 18, 2026
Business Standard
An illiberal tilt
We are witnessing a clash of civilisations with American characteristics
4 mins
February 18, 2026
Business Standard
Dr Reddy’s to launch generic obesity drug at 50-60% discount
Indian drugmaker Dr Reddy’s Laboratories hopes to launch a generic version of Novo Nordisk’s blockbuster weight-loss drug Wegovy at a competitive price that could be up to 60 per cent lower than the branded product, a top executive told Reuters on Tuesday.
1 min
February 18, 2026
Business Standard
India doesn’t need hand-down versions of AI products: Intel
The aspirations of India and the Global South are no less than those of other countries when it comes to artificial intelligence (AI) development across all layers of hardware and software, Santhosh Viswanathan, vice president and managing director (VP & MD) of Intel India, said on Tuesday.
1 mins
February 18, 2026
Business Standard
Focus on consumers
RBI's draft proposals will make banking experience better
2 mins
February 18, 2026
Listen
Translate
Change font size
