Facebook Pixel Sacred Silence | Outlook - news - Les denne historien på Magzter.com

Prøve GULL - Gratis

Sacred Silence

Outlook

|

May 01, 2025

While there are protests happening across many Indian cities after Parliament passed the controversial Waqf Bill, Kashmiris have chosen to stay silent, once again

- Toibah Kirmani IS A SUB-EDITOR AT OUTLOOK, BASED IN KASHMIR

Sacred Silence

EIGHTY-FOUR-year-old Yaseen Zahra sits on a wooden ledge covered with a faded namda (woollen rug) at the Khangah-e-Mo'alla, a 650-year-old shrine in the middle of Srinagar, built in the memory of a Sufi scholar and saint from Iran's Hamadan province, also known as Shah-e-Hamadan. Zahra is the mujawir (traditional caretaker of the shrine), like his father and his grandfather. He is among hundreds of mujawirs who were pushed aside after the Jammu and Kashmir Waqf Board—now under the control of the Union government since the abrogation of Article 370— issued a directive in August 2022. The board banned nazr-o-niyaz, the age-old practice of devotees offering alms to shrine caretakers. Zahra’s money box was taken away too.

“I don’t take a rupee,” he says. “Not from anyone. The income that comes from the shrine’s property goes to the government, including the money people leave in the donation boxes.” Still, he says he won't leave this place. “I've given my life to this place. I'll stay here as long as I breathe,” he says.

He nods towards an elderly man sweeping the courtyard. “He doesn’t get paid. He comes here because he wants to. Will the government, which measures everything in money, ever understand devotion that asks for nothing in return?”

In every corner of the Kashmir Valley, there are shrines, mosques, seminaries and Sufi lodges. Like many other places, in Kashmir too religious and charitable land was often created through oral trust-based agreements. A Sufi lodge might have been built where a mystic often stopped to pray and share his teachings with the local community.

According to data from the Jammu and Kashmir Waqf Board, over 32,000 kanals of land fall under its administration—one

FLERE HISTORIER FRA Outlook

Outlook

Outlook

The Spectacle of the Woman Accused

Media narratives—especially when women are involved—can end up amplifying suspicion and weaponising gender

time to read

7 mins

March 11, 2026

Outlook

Outlook

The Stink of Epstein

Why are the rich and powerful of the world scared of what lies buried in the Jeffrey Epstein files?

time to read

6 mins

March 11, 2026

Outlook

Outlook

Passing the Watermelon

Narendra Modi's presence in Israel is being read not just as a bilateral engagement, but as an endorsement of Israeli action in Gaza and the West Bank

time to read

5 mins

March 11, 2026

Outlook

Outlook

For Phoolan, Who Wasn't a Devi

“Whether or not it is the Truth is no longer relevant. The point is that it will, (if it hasn’t already) - become the Truth. Phoolan Devi, the woman has ceased to be important. (Yes of course she exists. She has eyes, ears, limbs, hair etc. Even an address now) But she is suffering from a case of Legenditis. She’s only a version of herself. There are other versions of her that are jostling for attention. Particularly Shekhar Kapur’s “Truthful” one, which we are currently being bludgeoned into believing.”–Arundhati Roy in ‘The Great Indian Rape-Trick I’, on the film Bandit Queen by Shekhar Kapur based on Phoolan, whom he never met because he didn’t think he needed to meet her. The film was based on journalist Mala Sen’s book India’s Bandit Queen: The True Story of Phoolan Devi.

time to read

5 mins

March 11, 2026

Outlook

Outlook

The Chic Cartel

Women are not just victims or side characters in recent crime-and-power OTT dramas. They are complex forces-capable of empathy, strategy and ruthlessness-whose narratives demand both recognition and reckoning

time to read

5 mins

March 11, 2026

Outlook

Outlook

The Hierarchy of Sympathy

In crimes against women, justice is shaped not only in courtrooms but in newsrooms where narrative determines whose suffering becomes national conscience and whose fades into procedural silence

time to read

5 mins

March 11, 2026

Outlook

Outlook

Dasyu Sundari

Media accounts simultaneously cast her as victim and avenger, until a life shaped by caste violence and gendered oppression was repackaged into a consumable myth of dishonour and revenge

time to read

8 mins

March 11, 2026

Outlook

Outlook

Prince Pervert

Are rumours of the death of the rule of law vastly exaggerated?

time to read

4 mins

March 11, 2026

Outlook

Together, Apart

Poonam Saxena's translations of Mannu Bhandari and Rajendra Yadav's memoirs present a portrait of the trailblazing Hindi writer-couple's marriage and of newly independent India

time to read

3 mins

March 11, 2026

Outlook

Outlook

The Great Indian Rape Trick'

The trope of transforming sexual violence against women into a springboard for rage that can only be channelled through counter-violence has long served as a popular framework in cinema, both globally and in India

time to read

6 mins

March 11, 2026

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size