Gå ubegrenset med Magzter GOLD

Gå ubegrenset med Magzter GOLD

Få ubegrenset tilgang til over 9000 magasiner, aviser og premiumhistorier for bare

$149.99
 
$74.99/År

Prøve GULL - Gratis

The problem with provenance

The Field

|

July 2023

Collectors love a good story and will often pay a premium for genuine, authenticated items. But as Roger Field explains, provenances can be frustratingly difficult to verify and just as tough to disprove

- Roger Field

The problem with provenance

PROVENANCE, provenance, provenance. This collecting phrase might have much the same ring and price-boosting effect on antiques and collectables as property's much-quoted location, location, location' but, unlike the latter, it comes with various caveats. Before you start quibbling, today's brilliant location is not in itself a guarantee of future perfection, as all it takes is the tap of a planning officer's e-signature to transform a location' plus into a blighted minus as a new road or housing development is plonked outside your back door. But try as sellers might to obfuscate and dissemble in their sales particulars, it is blinking obvious come viewing day if a property is in a great location, and worth a lot more, or not.

Provenances can be more complex, not least as the ungodly have been faking them to boost values for as long as they have been faking antiques themselves. The ancient Greeks merrily carved statues purportedly made by even more ancient Greeks to sell to their new Roman masters. I can picture an ancient Roman Del Boy cheerfully 'up-pricing' a bit of gaudy jewellery to a gullible-looking customer: "Honest guv, this was taken off that strumpet Cleopatra's body just after the snake got her. My life on it! This knife was used to kill Caesar." And, after a couple of generations of repetition, risible tosh morphs into value-enhancing history.

That's the problem with some provenances: they can be infuriatingly difficult to verify and just as hard to disprove. And we want to believe them as we all love a great story. Collectors will happily pay to add multiple zeroes to the price because Eric Clapton (genuinely) played on this guitar at that concert. Or for that particular sword that was no ifs, no buts used at Waterloo. That is where I am taking you next.

FLERE HISTORIER FRA The Field

The Field

The Field

Unexpected trout

A day spent chasing the plentiful, pristine wild brown trout that reside in small streams up and down the country proves the best sport doesn't always come with a hefty price tag attached

time to read

7 mins

September 2025

The Field

The Field

Beretta 688 Performance

Offering impressive specification and extensive adjustability at a competitive price, this new Sporter looks good and shoots steadily

time to read

4 mins

September 2025

The Field

The Field

A new chapter for a historic syndicate

As Ragley estate's Dunnington Sporting Club opens its doors - and its shooting opportunities - to non-members for the first time, a roving syndicate takes advantage of the exclusive sport on offer

time to read

7 mins

September 2025

The Field

The Field

Cutting the mustard

From table staples such as ketchup and mayonnaise to artisanal concoctions steeped in tradition, our fondness for condiments is both growing and evolving

time to read

7 mins

September 2025

The Field

Morale-boosting bottles

Whether you are in renovation hell, expecting good (or bad) news or simply need to stock up, this selection will ensure you are prepared for any eventuality

time to read

3 mins

September 2025

The Field

The Field

A hunt reborn

Drawing inspiration from the British hunting community but with Pakistan's culture and traditions at the forefront, the renowned Peshawar Vale Hunt is being returned to its former glory

time to read

8 mins

September 2025

The Field

The Field

Hunt-ride heroines

It takes a special blend of bravery and skill to succeed in the world of high-octane hunt rides – and it is the ladies leading the way

time to read

7 mins

September 2025

The Field

The Field

Calling it quits

Knowing exactly when it is right to call time on a canine companion's working career is one of the most difficult decisions a gundog owner will ever face

time to read

4 mins

September 2025

The Field

The Field

A day not to be mist

Freezing temperatures and poor visibility could not take the shine off the inaugural ladies' day at Cheney Longville in the heart of Shropshire

time to read

7 mins

September 2025

The Field

Cultivating hardness of heart

Being 'nice' doesn't cut it when it comes to true gardening excellence. Difficult though it may be, a touch of ruthlessness is often exactly what's required

time to read

3 mins

September 2025

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size