Facebook Pixel Culture of fear Time to look beyond toxic win-at-all-costs approaches | The Guardian - newspaper - Magzter.comでこの記事を読む

試す - 無料

Culture of fear Time to look beyond toxic win-at-all-costs approaches

The Guardian

|

December 09, 2024

Danny Care's stories about the England rugby environment under Eddie Jones reveal important insights into the ways that sport is experienced, organised and led.

- Cath Bishop

Culture of fear Time to look beyond toxic win-at-all-costs approaches

Beyond the shocking examples of belittling and bullying that he alleges, a picture emerges of an ongoing, highly damaging cultural illiteracy among players, coaches and leaders.

It's striking how hard it was for Care and his teammates to speak up, for 100kg men bursting with muscles in the most macho of sports to call out what, according to Care, they saw as abusive behaviour that demeaned and damaged players.

A cult-like code of silence has played out disastrously in other sports such as gymnastics and cycling; it feels as if there is still a sinister omertà latent in sport that needs addressing.

Speaking up is an essential component of "psychological safety", proven to be crucial to high-performing teams.

We need a new generation of informed leaders and coaches who understand how to approach the challenge of creating sufficient psychological safety for an athlete to thrive within an environment characterised by uncertainty, constant testing and ever higher standards.

Care's stories highlight what appears a gross imbalance of power between coach and athlete (and other staff) under Jones.

In competitive sport, selection is the all-powerful currency - if that sits in the hands of a coach unchecked, then long-term performance and wellbeing suffer.

In the atmosphere of fear and paranoia that Care describes, challenging the coach becomes unthinkable.

If no one else is open to listening, then there's nowhere to go.

In the working world, there are rigorous processes and whistleblowing mechanisms, or you can go and find another company.

But in rugby union there is only one England training centre.

The Guardian からのその他のストーリー

The Guardian

The Guardian

'We need a restart' Hungarians in Ukrainian town divided by more than geography

Across much of Ukraine, the election in Hungary is being followed with a singular hope: that Viktor Orbán, the Kremlin-friendly leader who has made opposition to Kyiv a centrepiece of his campaign, will be voted out after 16 years in office.

time to read

3 mins

April 11, 2026

The Guardian

The Guardian

Local elections Why Muslim voters are turning away from Labour to the Greens

Mohammed Suleman, a self-described \"straight-talking Geordie\", doesn't love politics. The taxi driver and businessman prefers to focus on community initiatives.

time to read

6 mins

April 11, 2026

The Guardian

The Guardian

The £21bn hills? Crunch time for huge unexploited seam of gold

When Fidelma O'Kane retired more than a decade ago from her career as a social worker and lecturer, she thought she would be \"travelling and having a glass of wine and eating chocolate and reading books\" in the quiet, hilly corner of rural County Tyrone where she has lived almost all her life.

time to read

6 mins

April 11, 2026

The Guardian

Jury trials Labour MPs propose new courts to hear sex offences

Labour MPs are hoping to hijack plans to cut back on jury trials in England and Wales by proposing specialist courts for sexual offences with fixed dates for trial.

time to read

2 mins

April 11, 2026

The Guardian

The Guardian

Legal first as abusive man whose wife took own life is given eight-year term

A man convicted of killing his wife, who took her own life after repeated domestic abuse, has been jailed for eight years in a case seen as a significant legal milestone.

time to read

3 mins

April 11, 2026

The Guardian

The Guardian

'She did it first' Pioneering Swedish artist finally given a solo exhibition

The Swedish artist Hilma af Klint died believing the world was not ready for the mystical paintings that would shock the art world half a century later.

time to read

2 mins

April 11, 2026

The Guardian

Interstellar musical lifts off

The scope and ambition of this dark musical by Theo Jamieson and Adam Lenson are boundless.

time to read

1 min

April 11, 2026

The Guardian

Nato Starmer appeals to US to stay in alliance and vows more European support

Keir Starmer has insisted it is in the best interests of the US to stay in Nato, saying Europe would do more to support the alliance in light of the war in Iran.

time to read

3 mins

April 11, 2026

The Guardian

The Guardian

Racing to be seen: trebles all round as young crowds turn out in force at Aintree

The Aintree morning was still young and the temperature low enough to justify a thick coat when Hayley Bentley arrived for Ladies'

time to read

3 mins

April 11, 2026

The Guardian

The Guardian

Press gala Unease as Trump set to speak at key dinner

Members of the White House Correspondents' Association are surely hoping that - Donald Trump will take a more diplomatic tone later this month when he makes his first appearance as US president at the organisation's glitzy dinner in Washington DC, an annual event meant to honour and celebrate journalists and press freedom.

time to read

2 mins

April 11, 2026

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size