試す - 無料

Why regimes collapse

Business Standard

|

September 13, 2025

To be truly functional and durable, even eternal, a state doesn't just need a leader, a party, or an ideology. It needs functional and robust institutions

- SHEKHAR GUPTA

Is there such a thing as a hard or a soft state? What if we said that any state is indeed just that, the state? It has to have it in its guts to stay together, cohesive, and orderly. That last is not my line. From whom it's borrowed, I'll tell you as we go along.

Take Nepal. The fall of its constitutionally elected government in just over a day of Gen Z protests in the capital is the third such in three years in the subcontinent, after Sri Lanka (Colombo, July, 2022) and Bangladesh (Dhaka, August, 2024). As we keep saying, invoking the primer of journalism, this conforms to the three-example rule. We can also note much clamour on social media, mostly from the Bharatiya Janata Party base, which includes many prominent and respected names, that this is just what the "powers that be" would want done with the Modi government in India. The regime-change toolkit, as they'd put it.

Let's also look at exceptions. Not every government collapses under a public protest. I know this is a super-provocative example, but remember Pakistan on May 9, 2023?

Imran Khan's supporters rioted not in one city but across many, even stormed Lahore's Jinnah House, the Corps Commander's home. The situation had many more ingredients for a "regime" overthrow than in Colombo, Dhaka or Kathmandu. A widely hated civilian government, the handmaiden of a then-reviled army, had jailed the most popular mass leader.

That "revolution" ended within 48 hours. The leader (Imran Khan) is still in jail, now handed a 14-year sentence, the same coalition is still in power, having been rebirthed through another rigged election, and all socio-economic and democratic grievances remain. More than 250 protest leaders are being tried in military courts. The state looks way stronger.

Business Standard からのその他のストーリー

Business Standard

NGT forms panel to curb Sunderbans coastal erosion

The National Green Tribunal (NGT) has constituted a joint committee to tackle the 'alarming' coastal erosion affecting the Sundarbans region of West Bengal, particularly Ghoramara Island.

time to read

1 mins

February 20, 2026

Business Standard

Onus on banks to ensure agents behave

RBI'S DRAFT DIRECTIONS FOR RECOVERY AGENTS

time to read

3 mins

February 20, 2026

Business Standard

Business Standard

Global CEOs call for inclusive use of AI

Strike note of optimism and urgency, calling AI as an opportunity for economic acceleration

time to read

2 mins

February 20, 2026

Business Standard

FMCG firms may see slow but steady growth in 2026

Numerator says categories that saw high growth are expected to normalise

time to read

1 min

February 20, 2026

Business Standard

Ashok Soota disagrees with Khosla, says AI is transforming IT

Ashok Soota, the founder and chairman of Happiest Minds Technologies, said the idea of IT services company turning redundant in five years due to the impact of artificial intelligence (AI) is misplaced as technology has always evolved to create newer opportunities.

time to read

1 min

February 20, 2026

Business Standard

Revitalising PPPs

India's experience with public-private partnerships (PPPs) offers a clear lesson. When designed and executed well, PPPs can transform infrastructure delivery; when poorly structured, they can stall development for years.

time to read

4 mins

February 20, 2026

Business Standard

Draft norms on INR derivative seen driving banks to GIFT City

The recent draft norms of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) allowing authorised dealers to undertake rupee non-deliverable derivative contracts (NDDCs) having operations in IFSC Banking Unit, will incentivise banks to deepen their presence in GIFT City in Gujarat’s Gandhinagar-Ahmedabad Metropolitan Region, said experts.

time to read

2 mins

February 20, 2026

Business Standard

Nothing looks to develop CMF as standalone brand

Launched its first flagship store in Bengaluru recently

time to read

1 mins

February 20, 2026

Business Standard

Aluminium long-term fundamentals constructive: Kotak Institutional Equities

Longer-term fundamentals for aluminium remain constructive despite a recent pullback in global prices of the industrial metal, Kotak Institutional Equities (KIE) has said.

time to read

1 mins

February 20, 2026

Business Standard

Business Standard

Disrupting the disruptor

With AI automating code, IT services firms must redefine their role. The pivot to AI-driven models marks a structural shift — one that is fundamentally changing the $285 bn industry

time to read

6 mins

February 20, 2026

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size