Essayer OR - Gratuit

There to Prevent terror – or free speech? Kenan Malik

The Observer

|

June 15, 2025

If you believe that immigration has destroyed western civilisation, I might think you've become too drunk on Robert Jenrick and Allison Pearson, Douglas Murray and Melanie Phillips. The British state, though, may well mark you down as being on the path to terrorism.

According to an online training course for Prevent, the government's anti-radicalisation programme, "cultural nationalism" defined as the belief that "'western culture' is under threat from mass migration and a lack of integration by certain ethnic and cultural groups" - is one of "the three most common subcategories of extreme rightwing terrorist ideologies", the others being "white/ethno-nationalism" and "white supremacism".

The claim inevitably drew outrage from rightwing commentators. Toby Young, founder of the Free Speech Union (FSU), wrote to the home secretary, Yvette Cooper, pointing out that Prevent's definitions of "extremism" and "terrorist ideologies" expand "the scope of suspicion to include individuals whose views are entirely lawful but politically controversial", and that "right-of-centre beliefs risk being treated as ideologically suspect".

Prevent, the FSU's Freddie Attenborough wrote in The Critic magazine, "has shifted from focusing on conduct (acquiring weapons, making threats, inciting violence) to treating political ideologies as indicators of risk - the problem being that 'risky' ideologies are both vaguely defined and culturally loaded".

PLUS D'HISTOIRES DE The Observer

The Observer

The Observer

Government accused of 'downplaying' data leak risk to Afghans who aided UK forces

A new report offers a stark contrast to the official review about the deadly effects of the information breach

time to read

4 mins

November 02, 2025

The Observer

The Observer

After the hurricane: will the human cost finally push Cop30 into action on climate crisis?

As politicians head to Brazil, Melissa offers a stark reminder of the consequences of failure to act. Climate editor

time to read

7 mins

November 02, 2025

The Observer

Why debt strategy is taking centre stage in Reeves's 'aggressive' plans

The bond markets, buyers and no less importantly - sellers of government bonds, hang like spectres over this year's budget.

time to read

4 mins

November 02, 2025

The Observer

The Observer

Open, ended: Allen lifts lid on the sexual chaos of non-monogamy

Singer's skewering of her actor husband has us hooked and asking: what the hell is happening in modern marriage and dating?

time to read

5 mins

November 02, 2025

The Observer

We're working to root out medical misogyny and ensure mothers' voices are heard

Medical misogyny has cast a long shadow over maternity care in this country. The conversations I've had with harmed and bereaved families have been profoundly shocking.

time to read

1 mins

November 02, 2025

The Observer

The Observer

Rio favelas mourn as deadliest police raid exposes deep divisions

Last week's operation, which left at least 121 people dead, has led to calls for the governor to go, but also demands for a tougher approach from President Lula

time to read

4 mins

November 02, 2025

The Observer

The gloves are off: Mary Earps hits out at England coach and fellow goalie

In a revealing new memoir, the Lionesses' former keeper criticises Sabrina Wiegman and exposes resentments in the squad, writes Jessy Parker Humphries

time to read

3 mins

November 02, 2025

The Observer

The Observer

Clinical negligence costs NHS almost the same as it spends on maternity care

Defensiveness and a hierarchical environment lead to cover-ups, says ombudsman

time to read

5 mins

November 02, 2025

The Observer

The Observer

Save us from ‘Shrekking’ - we have plenty of dating horrors already

In an ideal world, the young find their own way - but sometimes you have to intervene.

time to read

2 mins

November 02, 2025

The Observer

The Observer

Musk won't stop. It's time the government gave up on X for good

The platform has become a swamp of disinformation. Politicians should lead the way out, says Will Jennings

time to read

3 mins

November 02, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size