Essayer OR - Gratuit
Too much of a good thing
The Independent
|April 02, 2025
‘Adolescence’ has highlighted just how wholesome most primetime terrestrial TV has become. Phil Harrison wonders if we should call time on our diet of twee telly gentleness
There is no denying the essential appeal of Stacey Solomon and Joe Swash. As seen in new BBC reality show Stacey & Joe, their home life is almost exactly as you’d imagine – a bit chaotic but full of warmth and sweetness too. But this mediated narrative of fishing lakes, al fresco dining and avocado toast in bed does feel like the latest expression of a trend that’s been building interrestrial television for a while now. It’s a sort of performative cosiness; a default setting of placid, beige gentleness. Happy tears and hugging. There’s an earnestness about lots of primetime TV now that would have been seen as gauche 20 years ago.
When reality TV was born, it soon tested its limits and established its boundaries. Big Brother (and its celebrity variations) headed for the extremes fairly quickly. In reality TV (as in much of the comedy of the late Nineties and early Noughties), there was an unseemly taste for harshness, for cringe, maybe even for cruelty. There were millions of takers for the barely submerged sneering of Little Britain, for the necksnapping wince of Wife Swap, for the voyeuristic horror of The Jeremy Kyle Show. If normal people were going to be represented on TV, it seemed they’d better get used to being the targets of mockery. And they’d better be ready to sing for their supper.

Cette histoire est tirée de l'édition April 02, 2025 de The Independent.
Abonnez-vous à Magzter GOLD pour accéder à des milliers d'histoires premium sélectionnées et à plus de 9 000 magazines et journaux.
Déjà abonné ? Se connecter
PLUS D'HISTOIRES DE The Independent
The Independent
'British FBI' to fight serious crime, says home secretary
A new national police force dubbed the “British FBI” will take over counterterror, fraud and criminal gang investigations as part of a major shakeup of policing to be announced by the home secretary.
2 mins
January 25, 2026
The Independent
Burnham traps Starmer with bid to return as MP
Andy Burnham has confirmed he is seeking to stand for Labour in the Gorton and Denton by-election, paving the way for a return to parliament and a potential leadership challenge to Sir Keir Starmer.
5 mins
January 25, 2026
The Independent
Canada threatened with 100% tariffs over China deal
Donald Trump has threatened to “immediately” hit Canada with a 100 per cent tariff on all goods and products, should the country make a deal with China.
2 mins
January 25, 2026
The Independent
Trump climbs down over UK soldiers in Afghanistan
Donald Trump has climbed down over his slurs against British soldiers in Afghanistan after sparking widespread outrage for his false claims made about Nato allies.
3 mins
January 25, 2026
The Independent
Dairy farmer dodged HS2, but now faces gas pipeline
A dairy farmer whose farm escaped being cut in half by the scrapped HS2 railway line now faces having a huge underground gas pipeline running through his land.
3 mins
January 25, 2026
The Independent
'I'm 73 and terrified I'll die without knowing what became of my missing son'
In 1996, 16-year-old Damien Nettles disappeared on the Isle of Wight without a trace. As part of The Independent's SafeCall campaign, his mother speaks to Harriette Boucher
3 mins
January 25, 2026
The Independent
Liverpool stunned by last-gasp Bournemouth winner
Amine Adli scrambled home a winner in the fifth minute of added time as Liverpool's dismal title defence suffered another setback with a dramatic 3-2 defeat at Bournemouth.
2 mins
January 25, 2026
The Independent
Hacked-off Harry fighting for all of us to ‘read all about it’
Oceans of ink have been drained in trying to explain what Prince Harry hopes to achieve in the quietly spectacular drama currently being played out in Court 76 of the Royal Courts of Justice.
4 mins
January 25, 2026
The Independent
ON THIS DAY
AD76: The Roman emperor Hadrian was born. It was on his orders that Hadrian's Wall was built in Britain “to separate the Romans from the Barbarians”.
1 min
January 24, 2026
The Independent
Peace board puts Blair on a collision course with the PM
There was a time when prime ministers would quietly retreat into writing memoirs and lecturing on the after-dinner circuit.
4 mins
January 24, 2026
Listen
Translate
Change font size

