Essayer OR - Gratuit
True ugliness is editing out a disabled child from a school photo
The Guardian Weekly
|April 12, 2024
There is a difference between being shocked and being surprised. I thought of that as I read the news that disabled children had been "erased" from their class photo in a primary school in Aberdeenshire in Scotland.
A photographer is said to have taken separate pictures: one with the children with "additional needs" and one without. Parents were then given both versions to choose from. Reportedly, a set of twins was split up. The child who uses a wheelchair was excluded from one photo, while their twin, who isn't disabled, was photographed with the rest of the class.
If that feels somewhat chilling, it is because it should. Few of us cannot understand the connotations of wanting to pretend disabled children don't exist.
Indeed, in recent days the incident has been resolved with a swift consensus. The news went viral. The public expressed its outrage online. The photography company offered an apology. Lessons will be learned.
And yet this is neither the beginning nor the end of the story. One photographer did not invent ableism and the way those disabled children were treated will not be the first time such attitudes have bled into our schools.
Over the past few days, I have heard of cases of disabled children across the UK who have been "edited" in their school photo. Some have had their disability aids removed by photographers. Others have been altered with editing software or banned from their class photos.
Cette histoire est tirée de l'édition April 12, 2024 de The Guardian Weekly.
Abonnez-vous à Magzter GOLD pour accéder à des milliers d'histoires premium sélectionnées et à plus de 9 000 magazines et journaux.
Déjà abonné ? Se connecter
PLUS D'HISTOIRES DE The Guardian Weekly
The Guardian Weekly
Trump has shown there aren't any rules. We'll all regret that
I never thought it possible that you could look back on the Iraq war and feel some measure of nostalgia.
4 mins
January 09, 2026
The Guardian Weekly
The new world order 'according to Trump
With the audacious snatch and grab raid that extracted Nicolás Maduro to face trial in the United States, Washington sent a clear message to its allies and adversaries:
3 mins
January 09, 2026
The Guardian Weekly
The phone is ringing, but is it a scam? I'll ask my assistant
I am staring at my computer when my phone rings.
3 mins
January 09, 2026
The Guardian Weekly
The unlikely genius of Getdown Services
Scatological lyrics, social conscience, a commitment to fun and a shoutout from Walton Goggins - 2026 is going to be the laptop garage band's year
3 mins
January 09, 2026
The Guardian Weekly
Behind the race to get Americans back on the moon
With astronauts set to fly around the moon for the first time in more than half a century when Artemis 2 makes its ascent sometime this spring, 2026 was already destined to become a standout year in space.
3 mins
January 09, 2026
The Guardian Weekly
Striking it rich The US plan for involvement in Venezuela's 'bust' oil sector
The Venezuelan oil industry has been “a total bust” for a long time, according to Donald Trump.
2 mins
January 09, 2026
The Guardian Weekly
Life after extinction Science or science fiction?
A startup's plans for resurrecting lost creatures have caught the public's imagination but many researchers doubt that such a feat is possible
5 mins
January 09, 2026
The Guardian Weekly
It's a ridiculous time to be a man'
A group of male comedians is at the forefront of a new genre of social media comedy poking fun at our ever-shifting notions of modern masculinity
4 mins
January 09, 2026
The Guardian Weekly
Charting the global economy in 2026
With inflation predicted to cool, rising unemployment, weak growth and trade tensions pose fresh risks, while high debt and AI add to uncertainty in the year ahead
4 mins
January 09, 2026
The Guardian Weekly
High stakes for Mamdani as he must now deliver on his promises to New York
The multiple firsts achieved by New York’s new mayor, Zohran Mamdani, have been well chronicled: he is the first Muslim to occupy that role, the first south Asian and the first to be born in Africa.
2 mins
January 09, 2026
Listen
Translate
Change font size
