Essayer OR - Gratuit

Is it right or wrong to post about conflict on social media? Hannah Jane Parkinson

The Guardian Weekly

|

November 10, 2023

The welcome irony is that Martin Niemöller's words about not speaking out are everywhere. If you were not already familiar with First They Came, his urging of resistance in the face of tyranny and persecution, from history class or Holocaust documentaries, you may have seen it on Instagram during the past weeks.

- Hannah Jane Parkinson

Is it right or wrong to post about conflict on social media? Hannah Jane Parkinson

Niemöller's words, repurposed from a speech he gave in 1946, are a cautionary tale and mea culpa, deploring his own inertia in the face of Hitler's growing persecution of minority groups (the majority of victims, of course, Jews). His words, along with the Dietrich Bonhoeffer quote "Silence in the face of evil is itself evil", have spread on social platforms following the latest outbreak of war between Israel and Hamas.

It's hard to argue with Niemöller or Bonhoeffer and the belief that, as the saying goes: "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing." And yet, I hesitate to see the value in admonishments during the current conflict towards those who have kept their counsel online - from celebrities such as Jewish actor Noah Schnapp, who declared his feeds were "chillingly quiet" after Hamas's attacks on Israel, to Palestinians proclaiming that "the silence is deafening" after Israel's bombardment of Gaza.

PLUS D'HISTOIRES DE The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

I love when my enemies hate, me

Every day, Hasan Piker broadcasts a marathon Twitch stream, airing his views to 3 million followers. It has led to him becoming one of the biggest voices on the US left. But Piker's online fame has drawn vitriol towards him in real life

time to read

10 mins

January 02, 2026

The Guardian Weekly

Baseinstinct Why did Trump order airstrikes on Nigeria?

Claims that Christians face religious persecution overseas have become a major motivating force for Trump's base.

time to read

2 mins

January 02, 2026

The Guardian Weekly

Florence's outcasts A vivid and absorbing history of one of the first orphanages in Europe

Joseph Luzzi, a professor at Bard College in New York, is a Dante scholar whose books argue for the relevance of the Italian art and literature of the late middle ages and Renaissance to our own times.

time to read

1 mins

January 02, 2026

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

Need cheering up after a terrible year? I have just the story for you

Perhaps you are searching for reasons to be cheerful at the end of a particularly dispiriting year and the start of a new one that may well offer more of the same? In that case, read on.

time to read

4 mins

January 02, 2026

The Guardian Weekly

N347 Vegetable udon curry

You could also serve this with rice, but if you do, use only half the quantity of dashi, because this curry is made slightly soupier to go with the noodles.

time to read

1 mins

January 02, 2026

The Guardian Weekly

Warbling free The app that can tell birds by their songs

When Natasha Walter first became curious about the birds around her, she recorded their songs on her phone and arduously tried to match each song with online recordings.

time to read

2 mins

January 02, 2026

The Guardian Weekly

A soundtrack to all of humanity

The Nazis adopted Ode to Joy. Happy Birthday hides a tale of greed. And Putin has turned Shostakovich's Leningrad symphony into a call to arms. Is this the fate of musical utopias?

time to read

4 mins

January 02, 2026

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

Brigitte Bardot 1934 -2025

France's most sensational cultural export, who on screen epitomised youth, sex and modernity until politics and her campaigns for animal rights took over

time to read

3 mins

January 02, 2026

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

Who owns space? As the race starts to exploit the cosmos for commercial gains, we must act to preserve it for all humanity

If there is one thing we can rely on in this world, it is human hubris, and space and astronomy are no exception.

time to read

3 mins

January 02, 2026

The Guardian Weekly

Food for thought A personally inflected history of psychiatric ideas with flashes of anarchic humour

In 1973, US psychologist David Rosenhan published the results of an experiment.

time to read

3 mins

January 02, 2026

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size