Essayer OR - Gratuit

Life in Trumpian America is like the Salem witch trials

Daily Maverick

|

October 03, 2025

It is no longer the land of the free or the brave as citizens cower in fear of persecution or arrest

- Charmain Naidoo

Life in Trumpian America is like the Salem witch trials

(Photos: iStock: Freepik)

Sitting around a table in New York with a group of women celebrating the big birthday of a friend, I was smacked in the face by what it feels like to live in a society where education, status and citizenship are no longer a guarantee of safety from arrest, imprisonment or, worst of all, deportation.

I could smell the fear coming off the women - fear of reprisal for saying anything that goes against what is considered to be "acceptable" speech; fear of being cancelled, of having work contracts summarily ended. And in one case, of having one's immigration status revoked and being sent back to a country where you have not lived.

Welcome to Trumpian America, the land of the not so free and, certainly, the not so brave. The women at that table, all academics, all lecturers in their specific field of law, all from universities dotted across this vast country, had a story to tell, all of them tinged with the undertones of bullying, all laced with huge threads of trepidation.

The immigration law lecturer described how head-shakingly perplexed she is on a daily basis, as laws that were in the statute books last week might not apply this week. She tells how impossible it is to teach, to guide her students through the shifting quicksand parameters of immigration law.

What the inalienable rights of citizens were a month ago might no longer apply. She is at sea. How do you impart knowledge when the bottom has fallen out of what is, or rather was, written down as the benchmark for that particular subject?

US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is plucking people off the street every day, taking them to detention centres. People are randomly being asked to prove they are legally allowed to be in the US.

It reminds me of our own troubled history, when black South Africans had to carry a "dompas", the document that controlled black people's movement during apartheid.

PLUS D'HISTOIRES DE Daily Maverick

Daily Maverick

Daily Maverick

Sacrifices from both Israel and Hamas can end the war in Gaza

For the first time in two years of bloodshed, hope for a peace plan succeeding seems realistic. By Eyal Mayroz

time to read

6 mins

October 10, 2025

Daily Maverick

SA's Al policy refuses to take the human out of the machine

The proposed national Al framework prioritises flexibility over legislation, but the bottleneck may be in institutional hurdles.

time to read

4 mins

October 10, 2025

Daily Maverick

New book shines light on a vital Zimbabwean freedom fighter

Edson Sithole's mysterious disappearance has overshadowed his valuable contributions. By Brooks Marmon

time to read

5 mins

October 10, 2025

Daily Maverick

Inside Saica's fight to restore its credibility

In response to the original article, Saica members and the public expressed consistent frustration to Daily Maverick that disciplinary processes against members of the profession often seemed slow, with penalties lacking a deterrent effect.

time to read

2 mins

October 10, 2025

Daily Maverick

One Battle After Another. the revolution will be a mad caper

This action thriller's constant tug-of-war between raw reality and screwball absurdity makes for a distracting experience at times.

time to read

3 mins

October 10, 2025

Daily Maverick

Hail Mr Brown, a graduate of the illustrious Shadow State Academy

The man was a legend in his own corner of North West, but now he has been thrust onto the national stage, flaunting his talents for threats and the solicitation of 'donations' for all to see.

time to read

5 mins

October 10, 2025

Daily Maverick

Ensuring property transfers are fair for all heirs

The simplest way to stay evenhanded is to separate the two issues of occupying the house and ensuring that the ultimate value each child receives remains fair.

time to read

2 mins

October 10, 2025

Daily Maverick

Daily Maverick

ConCourt advances the rights of fathers and adoptive parents

Until now, South African law has discriminated against dads as well as couples who adopt children or use surrogacy to conceive in terms of who could claim maternity leave and for how long. By Dianne Hawker

time to read

4 mins

October 10, 2025

Daily Maverick

Daily Maverick

A city up for grabs: disaffected

More than 40% of Gauteng's citizens say no party speaks for them. With Johannesburg facing multiple crises, the job of mayor may be a poisoned chalice - but it's also the biggest prize in local politics. By Ferial Haffajee

time to read

2 mins

October 10, 2025

Daily Maverick

Daily Maverick

The key figures who are set to shape the Mkhwanazi inquiry

Parliament's ad hoc committee investigating Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi's allegations has begun its proceedings and will be calling numerous witnesses and evidence leaders to testify. By Suné Payne

time to read

4 mins

October 10, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size