SECONDS OUT
Evo UK|April 2024
Hyperhatch versus sports coupe, fourwheel drive opposes rear, auto confronts manual. Despite their differences, the AMG A45 S and BMW M2 are still close rivals, but which delivers the knockout?
STUART GALLAGHER
SECONDS OUT

AMG AND BMW M HAVE been taking shots at each other for decades, trading blows and more-powerful punches on each other up and down the product lines. So much so that the M development team stopped looking at what AMG was doing some time ago and instead turned to see what Porsche was up to, to determine what it had to do better to get the upper hand over its Affalterbach rivals.

It's a strategy that has seen M2s, 3s, 4s and 5s pull away from their A, C and E counterparts and continue to lord it over their rivals. Back-to-back eCoty wins with the M2 CS and M5 CS cemented M's return to form, although the M4 CSL dropped that ball before it was scooped up again by the M3 CS. BMW will be hoping for no further mishaps with the new hybrid-powered M5 later this year.

This match-up should be a foregone conclusion, then £67,030 M2 against the latest £63,285 A45 S. Rear-drive, straight-six engine, six-speed manual gearbox and the precision of an M differential against an eight-speed DCT, four-wheel-drive, highly strung four-cylinder hyperhatch with an aero kit to embarrass a Touring Car driver.

What the M2 lacks in technical armoury it makes up for by being little more than a cut-and-shut M4; it's the same width as its big brother at 1.8 metres, is only 21cm shorter overall and is taller by a hair's breadth. Which also explains why it weighs 1700kg.

And it feels as big as it looks. The optional carbon bucket seats swallow you whole, the window line rises up above your shoulder, the double-screen display fills your lower eyeline and even ardent BMW fans who enjoy sitting as close as possible to the floor might find the M2's seating position a little low. You're always conscious of your road position, too, making small adjustments to keep its Pilot 4 Ss between the white lines and away from the inevitable potholes.

Esta historia es de la edición April 2024 de Evo UK.

Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 8500 revistas y periódicos.

Esta historia es de la edición April 2024 de Evo UK.

Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 8500 revistas y periódicos.

MÁS HISTORIAS DE EVO UKVer todo
BEST BUYS AUDI RS
Evo UK

BEST BUYS AUDI RS

THERE'S NO GETTING AROUND IT: AUDI RS PRODUCTS haven't taken home nearly as many group-test trophies as BMW M cars have over the years.

time-read
10 minutos  |
June 2024
BMW M3 E46
Evo UK

BMW M3 E46

The E46 was the first M3 to be launched during evo's lifetime, and its unique. unrepeatable character ensures it remains one of the very best

time-read
8 minutos  |
June 2024
XX RATED
Evo UK

XX RATED

The Spider version of the SF90 XX provides our first taste of Ferrari's track-focused 1016bhp hypercar on the road

time-read
9 minutos  |
June 2024
RADICAL SR3 XXR & REVOLUTION 500 EVO
Evo UK

RADICAL SR3 XXR & REVOLUTION 500 EVO

No road car pretensions here: the Radical and Revolution sit where race car meets trackday car

time-read
7 minutos  |
June 2024
ANALOGUE ELISE & ALPINE A110 R
Evo UK

ANALOGUE ELISE & ALPINE A110 R

No-expense-spared restomod Elise by Analogue Automotive makes an intriguing pairing with the lightweight, track-focused A110 R

time-read
5 minutos  |
June 2024
FORD FOCUS ST TRACK PACK & HONDA CIVIC TYPE R
Evo UK

FORD FOCUS ST TRACK PACK & HONDA CIVIC TYPE R

The Civic Type R has so far seen off all challengers, but will it meet its match in the trackday-friendly Focus ST?

time-read
5 minutos  |
June 2024
TOYOTA GR86 & BBR MX-5
Evo UK

TOYOTA GR86 & BBR MX-5

GR86 and supercharged MX-5 look closely matched on paper; how will it prove on the twists and undulations of Cadwell?

time-read
4 minutos  |
June 2024
PORSCHE 911 GT3 RS
Evo UK

PORSCHE 911 GT3 RS

It’s the perfect blend of speed, poise and precision: what better car than the GT3 RS to establish our benehmark lap

time-read
5 minutos  |
June 2024
TRACK CAR OF THE YEAR
Evo UK

TRACK CAR OF THE YEAR

From hot hatches to flyweight sports cars to actual racers, 15 contenders vie to be crowned evo Track Car of the Year 2024

time-read
10+ minutos  |
June 2024
ORANGE RUSH
Evo UK

ORANGE RUSH

The new Vantage has the power and speed to take on the mighty Porsche 911 Turbo S, but is it all about the numbers or does it have the ability to engage and entertain too?

time-read
10+ minutos  |
June 2024