Reform's threat looms over UK politics

Labour's former shadow chancellor John McDonnell has declared that Keir Starmer's government has driven "a knife into the heart of what I believed Labour stood for" and called for party members, unions and MPs to take back control.

- MARTIN FARR

The text was McDonnell's, but the pretext was Nigel Farage. Earlier in the week, the Reform leader moved his tanks on to Labour's lawn by promising to reverse the government's withdrawal of winter fuel payments to pensioners, and remove the two-child benefit limit, a week after Starmer had committed the most perilous of political allusions: evoking the language of Enoch Powell over immigration. Starmer has been singed (as was Tony Benn in 1970) by playing with Powell's incendiarism. The disingenuousness of denials that so irregular a phrase as "an island of strangers" was not Starmer dog-whistling marked another low.

At the centre of Labour's dilemma is political mutability; how those most elemental, political categories "right" and "left" have blurred into indistinction. Reform UK were ostensibly of the former — nationalist, individualist, authoritarian — but now parade the sacraments of the latter: nationalisation, collectivism, welfarism.

Betrayal narratives follow Labour leaders as night does day, but Sir Keir Starmer's inconstancy and inability to offer mitigation by counter-narrative at least demonstrates his fidelity to his political hero Harold Wilson. His ministers in the 1960s and 1970s despaired at their electorally successful prime minister's apparent lack of defining principle.