Versuchen GOLD - Frei

To be avoided: Harry Potter and the Cursed Remake

The Independent

|

February 15, 2025

For any star to get involved in the HBO fantasy series would be a grave error for so many reasons, argues Louis Chilton

- Louis Chilton

To be avoided: Harry Potter and the Cursed Remake

Call it Harry Potter and the Cursed Casting Process. It has been nearly two years since Warner Bros announced the development of a lavish new TV series adapting JK Rowling’s fantasy novels, and there’s yet to be a single actor confirmed. This week, it was reported that John Lithgow (Dexter) is set to take on the role of Professor Dumbledore, the elderly wizard previously played on screen by the late Richard Harris, Michael Gambon and, in the abortive prequel saga, Jude Law.

Names such as I May Destroy You’s Paapa Essiedu have also been bandied around, reportedly in the running to play the oily Professor Snape. It’s easy to see why actors might be drawn to Harry Potter2.0: it’s lucrative, high-profile work, a TV show that YouGov polling suggests four in 10 Britons will watch. But make no mistake: this new series should have every sensible actor running for the hills.

Even if you leave aside the biggest and most intractable reason actors should steer clear of Potter – namely, Rowling – there are countless grounds why signing on would be a dicey proposition. For one, the previous adaptation (the eight-part Potter film series, which ran from 2001 to 2011) was beloved by fans, and remains, for many, definitive. If you’re an actor cast as Snape, for instance, and Alan Rickman’s career-defining performance is your yardstick, it’s going to be impossible to measure up. That producers will be hoping Potter runs for seven seasons – one per book, each corresponding to a school year at Hogwarts – only makes the project less appealing; it is a major commitment for most of the cast, one that will define an entire chunk of their professional lives.

WEITERE GESCHICHTEN VON The Independent

The Independent

ON THIS DAY

AD54: Roman Emperor Claudius I died after eating poisoned mushrooms as a result of a plot inspired by his wife, the Empress Agrippina.

time to read

1 mins

October 13, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Striking a powerful chord to destigmatise menopause

Well, this is a bit of a downer, isn't it? Those were my precise thoughts about halfway through the first episode of Riot Women, the new BBC One drama from Happy Valley mastermind Sally Wainwright. Like Happy Valley, it's set around Calderdale in West Yorkshire; like Happy Valley, its focus is firmly trained on women in midlife. But somehow, the introductory 30 minutes or so of Riot Women seemed to be even more depressing than a show that dealt with inherited trauma, addiction, murder and sexual assault. Or so I thought.

time to read

3 mins

October 13, 2025

The Independent

The next two days are critical for peace in Gaza

To describe the next 24 to 48 hours as crucial to the future of the Middle East would be an understatement. Even as the leaders of more than 20 countries, including the US president, prepare to converge on the Egyptian resort of Sharm El-Sheikh for the signing of the agreement that Donald Trump initiated, the risks are as evident as the hopes.

time to read

3 mins

October 13, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Added vow factor: inside India's fake wedding craze

In a country where weddings power an industry worth nearly £100bn and the uber-rich spend millions celebrating a single union, a counter-trend is quietly gaining ground: young urban Indians are paying to attend “weddings” where no couple is tying the knot and where the only promise is a night of music, dancing and spectacle.

time to read

5 mins

October 13, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

I felt a wave of disgust

The Independent's Arpan Rai tells of her anger after being barred from covering a Taliban leader's visit to India

time to read

3 mins

October 13, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Star was more complex than romcoms gave her credit for

Audiences adored Diane Keaton's klutzy charm - but beyond that persona lay an inspiring, restless artist, says Adam White

time to read

4 mins

October 13, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Shanghai Masters delivers a Cinderella story for the ages

When Valentin Vacherot arrived at the Shanghai Masters two weeks ago, he was ranked 204th in the world and did not even have a place in the tournament.

time to read

4 mins

October 13, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Why must we cast women in roles they never wanted?

For a long time, one of Hollywood’s most pressing questions was why Jennifer Aniston didn’t have children. It was right up there with why they ever did a second Sex and the City film and how Leonardo DiCaprio's girlfriends always seemed to stay 25.

time to read

2 mins

October 13, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Former MI6 chief questions collapse of China spy trial

There are growing questions over the collapse of a case against two men accused of spying for Beijing, with the former chief of the Secret Intelligence Service saying he is unsure why the prosecution was dropped.

time to read

3 mins

October 13, 2025

The Independent

The Independent

Police sexual misconduct claims double in five years

Sexual misconduct and discrimination complaints against police officers have doubled in five years - but more than half of claims have gone uninvestigated, The Independent can reveal.

time to read

3 mins

October 13, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size