Springboks overcome iffy officiating to beat Italy
Sunday Tribune
|November 16, 2025
FOR several reasons, the Springboks' 32-14 defeat of Italy in Turin must rank among Rassie Erasmus' top 10 most gratifying wins, given this was a performance of the highest standards in the face of rank adversity. I can picture Erasmus in the Bok change room saying, "The officials can throw whatever they want at us, but we will suck it up and show them the middle finger.
This unbelievably dramatic game will sadly be recalled for the ridiculous red card given to Franco Mostert, but it should equally be revered as a match where the Springboks confirmed they are one of the greatest teams to grace the game, as they once more found a way to win against the odds.
The wonderful Schalk Burger in the SuperSport studio best summed up the red-card disaster that struck the Boks when he said, "The referees are coming up with more fiction than Hollywood's script writers."
Schalk nailed it. For the second week in a row, a Springbok lock was given a permanent red card by the on-field referee, with no thought given to the proper process of referring the matter to the bunker, where officials can look at all the angles and arrive at the right decision.
If the Lood de Jager decision last week against France was harsh, the Mostert punishment was diabolical, mostly because replays showed that it was totally unwarranted his shoulder did not make contact with the head of flyhalf Paolo Garbisi in the 11th minute.
Further, for the referee to say there were no mitigating circumstances is pathetic because, as Mostert was preparing for the tackle, Ethan Hooker tackled Garbisi and lowered his height.
It is wrong that inept officials are permitted to ruin the games for the spectators by making massively impactful errors.
Diese Geschichte stammt aus der November 16, 2025-Ausgabe von Sunday Tribune.
Abonnieren Sie Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierter Premium-Geschichten und über 9.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.
Sie sind bereits Abonnent? Anmelden
WEITERE GESCHICHTEN VON Sunday Tribune
Sunday Tribune
New Year, New You: strategies to make your resolutions stick
AH, THE magic of New Year's resolutions.
3 mins
January 04, 2026
Sunday Tribune
South Africa and Nigeria's rivalry: a call for self-reflection
SOUTH Africa's longstanding rivalry with Nigeria now plays out as much online as it does on the sports field, with citizens of both nations often trading barbs over even the pettiest of issues.
1 mins
January 04, 2026
Sunday Tribune
Chelsea interim boss McFarlane braces for Man City clash
CHELSEA interim boss Calum McFarlane was officially introduced to the squad on Friday after a \"crazy 24 hours\" following Enzo Maresca's exit, with Manchester City looming.
3 mins
January 04, 2026
Sunday Tribune
Bafana ready to reset against Cameroon
BAFANA Bafana midfielder Sphephelo
2 mins
January 04, 2026
Sunday Tribune
Key Sundowns players under the spotlight as Premiership return looms
THE 2025/26 Betway Premiership is shaping up to be one of the most compelling seasons in recent memory.
2 mins
January 04, 2026
Sunday Tribune
The post-apartheid crisis of ideas
\"AFRICA'S problem is not that it is traditional; it is that it has failed to modernise its traditions.\"
4 mins
January 04, 2026
Sunday Tribune
International and national political dynamics that shaped SA in 2025
THIS year will go down as one that offered fascinating developments for South Africa from a geopolitical perspective but also tested the balance of power in the country's political systems.
6 mins
January 04, 2026
Sunday Tribune
Dramatic Pead try after the hooter sinks Sharks in thriller at the Tank
JP Pietersen’s dream start to life as Sharks head coach came to end in dramatic fashion at Kings Park yesterday afternoon, when a try after the hooter by Junior Springbok scrumhalf star Haashim Pead secured the visitors a narrow 23-22 United Rugby Championship victory.
2 mins
January 04, 2026
Sunday Tribune
World Cup 'deserving' Linde reckons MI Cape Town can bounce back
ALL-ROUNDER George Linde feels he deserves his spot in the Proteas World Cup squad, and believes his MI Cape Town teammates can bounce back after winless record four matches into the new SA20 season.
2 mins
January 04, 2026
Sunday Tribune
Historic clash: Bafana v Cameroon
SOUTH Africa’s Bafana Bafana and Cameroon's Indomitable Lions will face off in the CAF 2025 Round of 16, rekindling a historic rivalry.
2 mins
January 04, 2026
Listen
Translate
Change font size
