Mit Magzter GOLD unbegrenztes Potenzial nutzen

Mit Magzter GOLD unbegrenztes Potenzial nutzen

Erhalten Sie unbegrenzten Zugriff auf über 9.000 Zeitschriften, Zeitungen und Premium-Artikel für nur

$149.99
 
$74.99/Jahr

Versuchen GOLD - Frei

The Raj extracted $65 trillion from us: Fact or fiction?

Mint Bangalore

|

January 29, 2025

Oxfam's huge estimate does not withstand scrutiny as it makes too many flimsy assumptions

- TIRTHANKAR ROY

xfam, in its report Takers not Makers, claims Imperial Britain "extracted" $65 trillion from India between 1765 and 1900 in today's money, "enough to carpet London with £50 notes" four times over, taking these numbers from calculations others have done before. The origins go back to Dadabhai Naoroji, who, writing 125 years ago, called the outflow a "drain." Oxfam uses the number to support a modern-day movement: a case for reparations Britain should pay India.

Such numbers are more than a criticism of Raj policies. There are plenty of grounds to criticize these. For example, it spent too little on welfare and infrastructure and too much on the army. But extraction data doesn't just put public policy but the entire colonial system to critical scrutiny. It is a case against the combination of colonialism and globalization that made the 19th century special.

Private capital worldwide made heavy use of the open economy protected by the British Empire, with goods, capital, labour and knowledge transacted more freely than in the mid-20th century, when barriers of all kinds went up. In the 20th century, Marxist intellectuals and nationalists said this capitalism had impoverished India by draining India's surplus to Britain. As global Marxist movements declined in the 1980s and 90s, the drain receded into academic obscurity. Historian Kirti Chaudhuri called the drain theory "confused" economics, "coloured by political feelings." I have criticized it too.

WEITERE GESCHICHTEN VON Mint Bangalore

Mint Bangalore

Mint Bangalore

Our new employment compact promises dignity with prosperity

The imperative of labour reforms is to ensure that its benefits reach those whose aspirations will shape our economic progress

time to read

3 mins

November 26, 2025

Mint Bangalore

Mint Bangalore

Xi raises Taiwan again in a call with Trump

When Xi Jinping and Donald Trump sat down in South Korea last month to discuss a pause in their trade war, Taiwan surprisingly didn’t come up. Now the biggest flashpoint between the US and China is firmly back on the agenda.

time to read

1 min

November 26, 2025

Mint Bangalore

Mint Bangalore

Zappfresh builds cold-chain muscle to push frozen foods

Recently listed Zappfresh is preparing to make its boldest bet yet.

time to read

2 mins

November 26, 2025

Mint Bangalore

Mint Bangalore

JioMart pulled up for uncertified walkie-talkies

India's top consumer watchdog has held Reliance JioMart guilty of misleading advertisements and unfair trade practices by allowing the sale of uncertified walkie-talkies on its platform, government officials aware of the matter said, in a first such action against an e-commerce portal.

time to read

1 mins

November 26, 2025

Mint Bangalore

Volcanic ash disrupts flights ops

Ash clouds from volcanic eruption in Ethiopia reached parts of India on Tuesday affecting flight operations but it had no impact on the weather or air quality, according to government agencies.

time to read

1 min

November 26, 2025

Mint Bangalore

Lord’s Mark Industries Ltd. acquires Renalyx, redefining the future of dialysis

Lord’s Mark Industries Ltd., a diversified healthcare and technology-led group, announced the acquisition of an 85% stake in Renalyx Health Systems Private Limited—the Bengaluru-based, med-tech innovator behind India’s first fully indigenous, Al and cloud-enabled smart hemodialysis machine.

time to read

1 mins

November 26, 2025

Mint Bangalore

Mint Bangalore

TechM lags peers but sticks to its turnaround timeline

Co. expects revenue growth to rise as macroeconomic conditions improve by March 2027

time to read

3 mins

November 26, 2025

Mint Bangalore

Retail scramble on NSE drives delivery volumes to a record

Cash delivery volumes on India's largest stock exchange surged more than 50% to a record in the current fiscal year, driven by unprecedented retail flows.

time to read

1 min

November 26, 2025

Mint Bangalore

Mint Bangalore

Tata Motors PV brings back Sierra to rival Creta, Vitara

Firm revives the iconic model after 22 years to push into the crowded mid-size SUV market

time to read

2 mins

November 26, 2025

Mint Bangalore

Let ‘nowcasts’ precede our economic numbers

‘Nowcasting’ that captures data from early indicators could aid policymaking, especially in the face of high economic uncertainty. But it must supplement existing data, not supplant it

time to read

2 mins

November 26, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size