Versuchen GOLD - Frei

New York, New Comrade

Business Standard

|

June 28, 2025

Zohran Mamdani's faith, support for Gaza, and dislike of Modi and Netanyahu are reasons why many in India are unhappy to see his rise, rather than celebrate it as another

- SHEKHAR GUPTA

New York, New Comrade

Zohran Mamdani is going to be in the "talk", not just in New York City or American politics, but also in India. Or, rather than saying that he will be in the headlines, we could use language more apt for the digital era and his demographic: He's going to be a most searched name for some time.

There's enormous oomph to a 33-year-old, super-stylish and articulate Muslim of Indian origin, who is now a frontrunner to govern the most powerful, rich, Jewish, and cosmopolitan city in the world. In India, it has played into the Hindu-Muslim binary. In the minds of the Hindu Right, it is the conquest of another great global city by a Muslim from the sub-continent. Sadiq Khan of London being the other.

His support for Gaza, strong anti-Trumpism (in the US President's own borough), and endorsement by the Democratic Left make him a personality important enough for Donald Trump to write a long post on.

He's paid him "compliments" like "a 100% Communist lunatic", one who "looks terrible, his voice is grating" and so on. Of course, he also links his rise to his pet hate — the quartet of women politicians on the Democratic Left who he calls "the Squad", led by New York Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez or AOC.

The President's choice of words is, of course, Trumpian. In the Trump world, "Communist" or "lunatic" might be common enough description for anybody he dislikes, used as casually as old Captain Haddock of Tintin comics dismissing somebody as a pestilential pachyderm or, simply, a vegetarian. To be abused by President Trump isn't a liability in New York.

Do I have a problem, or even an opinion on Mr Mamdani's rise? The answers are: Problem, no; and opinion, it's great to see Indians rise in Western democracies. We took pride in Rishi Sunak, on the Indian Right, Kash Patel, Jay Bhattacharya, and even Hindu American Tulsi Gabbard are celebrated, as is the star cast of "Indian" CEOs. Mr Mamdani will be a stellar addition.

WEITERE GESCHICHTEN VON Business Standard

Business Standard

Labour Codes impact: HCL tech profit slips 11%

Q3 top line beats Street estimates, bottom line misses expectations

time to read

2 mins

January 13, 2026

Business Standard

New labour Codes, restructuring weigh on TCS earnings

Tata Consultancy Services (TCS), India’s largest information technology (IT) services firm, saw its profit impacted in the October-December quarter by restructuring and changes in labour Codes.

time to read

1 min

January 13, 2026

Business Standard

Business Standard

Black drives the thrill for car buyers

Sees a surge in yearly sales, while white remains practical 'utility king'

time to read

2 mins

January 13, 2026

Business Standard

CHOOSING THE RIGHT B-SCHOOL TO MATCH YOUR CAREER GOALS

Success comes when you pick an institution that fits your professional dreams and your personality, helping you become the leader you want to be

time to read

2 mins

January 13, 2026

Business Standard

Business Standard

China’s PVC rethink to help India pipe makers

Supply likely to tighten after S-PVC rebate withdrawal

time to read

2 mins

January 13, 2026

Business Standard

Responsible growth

India must ensure data centres are sustainable

time to read

2 mins

January 13, 2026

Business Standard

India’s GenZ is full of creativity: PM

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Monday said India's GenZ is full of creativity and with innovative ideas, energy and purpose, the country’s youth is at the forefront of nation-building.

time to read

1 min

January 13, 2026

Business Standard

Business Standard

Iran wants to negotiate after threats to attack, says Trump

At least 572 killed in protests; Tehran says situation ‘under full control’

time to read

2 mins

January 13, 2026

Business Standard

Insurers knock on Irdai door for clarity on director overlap ban

CLAUSE THREATENS BOARD STRUCTURES AT BANK-BACKED FIRMS SAYS INDUSTRY

time to read

2 mins

January 13, 2026

Business Standard

Delhi HC allows Zydus to sell generic version of cancer drug

Citing public interest, the Delhi High Court has cleared the way for Zydus Life-sciences to proceed with the sale of its version of the cancer drug nivolumab in India.

time to read

1 min

January 13, 2026

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size