Irishman Brian MacNeice wasn’t the most popular man in Edinburgh last night after his deliberations for fully four minutes prompted referee Nic Berry to disallow what would have been a winning try for Scotland replacement Sam Skinner in the final play of the match.
Up in the Scots’ coaching box and around the ground, supporters started to celebrate as replays appeared to show the Edinburgh lock had grounded the ball after a last-ditch onslaught on the French line.
But Berry, who had a decent view at ground level, decided he couldn’t give a try based on what he could see and referred it upstairs.
During the course of the conversation that followed, the Australian whistler appeared to change his mind at one point before being directed to a different angle by MacNeice and ultimately deciding he didn’t have “conclusive evidence” to overturn his original ‘no-try’ verdict.
Cue frustration and dejection from the hosts and elation from the French, who ended a harrowing week with a precious Six Nations victory that had looked beyond them for most of this contest.
After their crushing opening defeat by Ireland in Marseille, there was plenty more vulnerability on show here but Fabien Galthie’s side showed character and composure to fight back in the final quarter.
With a home match against Italy next, their campaign is back on the rails while Scotland’s hopes of launching a title challenge suffered a major setback.
When Finn Russell’s third penalty put them 16- 10 ahead just before the hour, they appeared to be heading for victory but ultimately they could not close out the contest and paid a heavy price.
Diese Geschichte stammt aus der February 11, 2024-Ausgabe von The Rugby Paper.
Starten Sie Ihre 7-tägige kostenlose Testversion von Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierte Premium-Storys sowie über 8.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.
Bereits Abonnent ? Anmelden
Diese Geschichte stammt aus der February 11, 2024-Ausgabe von The Rugby Paper.
Starten Sie Ihre 7-tägige kostenlose Testversion von Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierte Premium-Storys sowie über 8.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.
Bereits Abonnent? Anmelden
Morris hat-trick lifts Steelmen
HOOKER Ieuan Morris came off the bench to settle matters for Ebbw Vale at Carmarthen Quins with his stunning second half hat-trick completing a 39-11 victory in Super Rygbi Cymru.
Joe keen to follow in family footsteps
JOE Ford is leading the charge to take Doncaster Knights to the promised land but says they have a long way to go before that becomes reality.
Robson keen to make it to the top with Coventry
COVENTRY ended the first five-match block of fixtures as the Championship’s only unbeaten side and full-back Charlie Robson has his sights set on promotion, and eventually playing for England.
Hancox joins the 200 club
AFTER 10 years of donning the red, black and yellow shirt for Bournemouth, skipper Grant Hancox made his 200th appearance this month after their Regional 2 South Central clash against Winchester.
Bear keen to be a big hit Down Under
FORMER Cornish Pirates back row Bear Williams has flourished in making the difficult transition from rugby union to league and has plans to play in Australia’s NRL. `
To play in two World Cups was a dream
RUGBY started quite late for me.
Call time on this pantomime ploy
THIS 60-second shot clock twaddle. If we must continue to plough down this blind alley it needs to apply from the moment the referee awards the penalty. If the authorities are going to put some stick about at least do it properly and with conviction.
Coetzee's pulling his weight again
WHETHER he starts or comes off the bench, Jaco Coetzee is just happy to be contributing fully to Bath’s revival after an injury-hit start to his career in blue, black and white.
Murray's on a wing - and a prayer ...
BLAIR Murray began the week ‘in a state of shock’ at having gone from nowhere on one side of the world to the starting grid for the autumn Tests on the other.
We need to kick on after winning at last
Paul Rees talks to Ethan Grayson who heard from two rugby legends after he helped Newcastle end their 25-match losing run