Mit Magzter GOLD unbegrenztes Potenzial nutzen

Mit Magzter GOLD unbegrenztes Potenzial nutzen

Erhalten Sie unbegrenzten Zugriff auf über 9.000 Zeitschriften, Zeitungen und Premium-Artikel für nur

$149.99
 
$74.99/Jahr

Versuchen GOLD - Frei

Salary sticks

New Zealand Listener

|

29 November-December 5 2025

Most discussions around pay equity involve raising women's wages to the equivalent of men's. But there is an alternative.

- BY SOPHIE MOULLIN

Salary sticks

Thank you for inviting me to prepare this brief analysis of the proposed Pay Equity Second Amendment (Swings and Roundabouts) Bill.

I was astounded to hear of the government's bold proposal to save approximately $0.6 billion per annum in public spending by securing pay equity between men and women. Levelling wages in male-dominated occupations down to those in female-dominated fields of equivalent skill and responsibility is, by any measure, an ambitious move that, to my knowledge, has never been attempted by any government anywhere.

Undoubtedly, the proposal is well-intentioned and, I am told, popular with the ladies across all party affiliations. In this submission, I acknowledge the potential merits of downward pay equity. However, as an apolitical economic expert, I feel compelled to alert Parliament to the risks this naive policy poses to macroeconomic stability and national competitiveness.

I can see the political appeal of pay equity. Although many men still shirk frontline public service roles, implementing immediate pay equity among direct government employees - levelling every corrections officer's pay down to that of a nurse, for instance - could free up a whole 1% of public spending to do a lobbyist a favour.

Private companies contracting with the government stand to pocket even more savings as pressure for downward pay equity spreads. Parity between construction supervisors ($52/hr) and aged-care supervisors ($32/hr), for example, could deliver an estimated 38% reduction in labour costs with only modest losses in retention, productivity and public confidence.

WEITERE GESCHICHTEN VON New Zealand Listener

New Zealand Listener

Hum dinger

The year's NZ music books have a high-volume encore.

time to read

2 mins

December 20-26, 2025

New Zealand Listener

Slap the slop this summer

2025 was the year Al slop oozed into every corner of the internet. I'm taking the summer to go cold turkey.

time to read

2 mins

December 20-26, 2025

New Zealand Listener

Shelling out

Eggshells are a great source of calcium, but think again if you're contemplating adding them to your diet.

time to read

2 mins

December 20-26, 2025

New Zealand Listener

New Zealand Listener

Heavyweight division

Mark Broatch checks out the year's best coffee table books.

time to read

3 mins

December 20-26, 2025

New Zealand Listener

New Zealand Listener

As bad as it gets

Veteran filmmaker wide of the mark in dated political comedy drama.

time to read

1 mins

December 20-26, 2025

New Zealand Listener

New Zealand Listener

Inspect a gadget

The 10 best tech upgrades of 2025.

time to read

4 mins

December 20-26, 2025

New Zealand Listener

New Zealand Listener

To absent friends

A search of Listener issues from ages past reveals the lack of classy wines was long lamented.

time to read

2 mins

December 20-26, 2025

New Zealand Listener

New Zealand Listener

That thinking feeling

Far from being emotionally driven, gut feelings can help us to make the best decisions, says a US expert on entrepreneurialism.

time to read

9 mins

December 20-26, 2025

New Zealand Listener

Diamonds in the rough

In a year in which our usual sources of sporting pride stumbled, some unlikely heroes sparkled.

time to read

7 mins

December 20-26, 2025

New Zealand Listener

New Zealand Listener

Thai up

Rocker Jimmy Barnes and wife Jane deliver seasonal recipes with an accent on Southeast Asia.

time to read

4 mins

December 20-26, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size