Matt Elton: How important is it to understand the history of Afghanistan to make sense of recent events?
Bijan Omrani: It’s vital. Afghanistan’s long history, and the way in which that history is a result of its geography and ethnic make-up, plays a crucial role in the forces acting on the nation today. The fact that neighbouring regions have frequently tried to treat Afghanistan as a frontier territory, despite its geography not really offering easy territory for it to be a frontier, has been a real motor for the way in which the region has developed.
William Dalrymple: The history of foreign interventions in Afghanistan haunts its former invaders, who came to a variety of unsatisfactory ends – whether withdrawal, bankruptcy, or outright defeat – and the Afghans themselves, who have a rich historiography of remembering those interventions. They look on the defeat of the East India Company in 1842, for example, as people in Britain look on the battle of Trafalgar: as a foundational narrative of the state.
Elisabeth Leake: It is, without question, important to think about Afghanistan’s history to understand the current moment. But we also need to be very careful and nuanced in the way in which we engage with that history, and recognise its vibrancy and texture. A key problem in 21st-century western media coverage of Afghanistan is a focus on a set of key tropes that people often assume define its past. One is to see the nation as an “outlier”, instead of thinking about the political and social dynamics that have emerged as a result of international relations and its relationship with its neighbours. Only by taking a more expansive view of Afghanistan and its people can we thoroughly understand what’s going on now.
Diese Geschichte stammt aus der December 2021-Ausgabe von BBC History Magazine.
Starten Sie Ihre 7-tägige kostenlose Testversion von Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierte Premium-Storys sowie über 8.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.
Bereits Abonnent ? Anmelden
Diese Geschichte stammt aus der December 2021-Ausgabe von BBC History Magazine.
Starten Sie Ihre 7-tägige kostenlose Testversion von Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierte Premium-Storys sowie über 8.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.
Bereits Abonnent? Anmelden
"It had been a tiny triumph, but it had been a British triumph"
MAX HASTINGS talks to Rob Attar about a daring airborne raid that provided a much-needed boost to Britain's morale in the darkest days of the Second World War
Dancing with the Devil
ROGER MOORHOUSE is impressed by a book that traces the fortunes of the diplomats charged with managing the west's wartime alliance with Josef Stalin
Victorian cucumber ice cream
ELEANOR BARNETT samples the delights of an unusual and refreshing version of one of the world's favourite summer treats
Anne Boleyn, ‘princess' of France
JOANNE PAUL is impressed by an account of how the Tudor queen's continental connections shaped her meteoric rise and dramatic fall
FIVE THINGS YOU (PROBABLY) DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT...Roman Britain
Rob Collins, who is teaching our new HistoryExtra Academy course, shares five surprising facts about life in Britain during the Roman occupation
War and pieces
Far from idle pursuits, games have transformed the way societies have made sense of life and death, order and conflict for centuries. Kelly Clancy picks five examples that reveal how playtime has often been a serious business
Gulbadan Begum The Mughal Jane Austen
Gulbadan Begum was meant to live a quiet life in the confines of a Mughal harem. Instead she made her mark on history twice: first, embarking on a pioneering pilgrimage to Islam’s holy cities; second, writing a remarkable history of her dynasty. RUBY LAL tells her story
Succession 1603
The passing of the English crown from Elizabeth I to James VI & I was welcomed by a nation hungry for change. But, writes Susan Doran, it wasn't long before tensions began to rise between the incoming king and his new subjects
Horror in France
On the morning of 10 June 1944, the residents of Oradour-sur-Glane were going about their lives as normally as was possible in occupied France: cooking, washing, shopping, playing. Little did they know that they were about to become the victims of one of the most infamous massacres of the Second World War.
"IT'S TIME TO WRITE WOMEN BACK INTO THESE WORLD-CHANGING ANCIENT EVENTS"
Daisy Dunn tells the story of the Greco-Persian Wars through the deeds of the extraordinary female figures who shaped them