Versuchen GOLD - Frei
Skip The Chorus
The Walrus
|March 2018
In the age of streaming and sharing, old formulas for what makes a hit are fading away
ONE FALL AFTERNOON, my friend Justice and I met up in a park near my apartment in East Vancouver for a song writing session. We’d both been listening to Bon Iver’s album 22, A Million, a collection of songs with abstract, often distorted, lyrics and frequently without traditional verse/chorus structures. Here’s the verse, now the chorus, maybe a bridge — so much popular music of the last century has had these familiar signposts. On this album, it’s the layers of sonic textures — synthesizers, saxophones, affected vocals — that draw you in. Bon Iver is not alone in this; off the top of my head, I could name a number of chorusless songs by other influential artists, such as Father John Misty’s “I’m Writing a Novel,” or Sufjan Stevens’s “Death with Dignity.” My friend and I were so fired up about the conversation that day that I got to thinking, Is the chorus dead?
On mainstream radio, for as long as I’ve been alive, the chorus has reigned supreme. My introduction to Western pop music was via a pocket sized radio I had in the 1970s and 1980s that churned out three and half minute songs with simple, catchy choruses I could learn in a single play. Later, when I started writing my own music, I adhered to the familiar formula. Choruses are radio friendly—a sonic marker in an era where some listeners flip “every fifteen seconds,” according to an executive I talked to — so it makes sense that musicians would try to write for that format. If you’re a song writer, you’ve probably heard the expression “don’t bore us, get to the chorus” (also the name of a 1995 greatest hits collection by Roxette), and I agree that it’s an effective approach to songwriting.
Diese Geschichte stammt aus der March 2018-Ausgabe von The Walrus.
Abonnieren Sie Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierter Premium-Geschichten und über 9.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.
Sie sind bereits Abonnent? Anmelden
WEITERE GESCHICHTEN VON The Walrus
The Walrus
Even Pigeons Are Beautiful
I CAN TRACE MY personal descent into what science journalist Ed Yong calls “birder derangement syndrome” back to when I started referring to myself as a “sewage lagoon aficionado.
5 mins
September/October 2025
The Walrus
MY GUILTY PLEASURE
BLAME IT ON my love of language, and blame that on my dad—the “it” being my unhealthy need for the stories of P. G. Wodehouse. The witty, wonderful, meandering, wisecracking tales of Jeeves and Bertie; Empress of Blandings (a prize pig) and her superbly oblivious champion, the ninth Earl; Mr. Mulliner; and the rest. Jeeves, the erudite, infallible, not to mention outrageously loyal valet to Bertram Wooster, the quite undeserving but curiously endearing man about town, is likely the most famous of these characters. But they’re all terrific, I assure you.
2 mins
September/October 2025
The Walrus
When It's All Too Much
What photography teaches me about surviving the news cycle
5 mins
September/October 2025
The Walrus
Annexation, Eh
The United States badly needs rare minerals and fresh water. Guess who has them?
10 mins
September/October 2025
The Walrus
We travel to transform ourselves
I grew up in Quebec during the time of the two solitudes, when the French rarely spoke to the English and anglophones could live and work in the province for decades without having to learn a word of French.
4 mins
September/October 2025
The Walrus
How to Win an 18th-Century Swordfight
Duelling makes a comeback
9 mins
September/October 2025
The Walrus
Getting Things Right
How Mavis Gallant turned fact into truth
7 mins
June 2025
The Walrus
Mi Amor
Spanish was the first language I was shown love in. It's shaped my understanding of parenthood
14 mins
June 2025
The Walrus
Odd Woman Out
Premier Danielle Smith is on Team Canada —for now
7 mins
June 2025
The Walrus
My GUILTY PLEASURE
THERE IS NO PLEASURE quite like a piece of gossip blowing in on the wind.
3 mins
June 2025
Translate
Change font size
