يحاول ذهب - حر
Gagging scientists is a lousy idea
February 16, 2023
|Down To Earth
Science needs to be open; the silencing of experts by the Modi regime on critical issues is against the public interest
-
WHEN DEEPAK Pental’s highly contested genetically modified (GM) mustard, dmh-11, was approved for environmental release in late 2022 after being in cold storage for many years, there was a furore. This was predictable, since the question of using genetically modified seeds for food crops is far from being settled. India’s farmers, proponents of sustainable agriculture, consumers and, most importantly, scientists, had challenged the technology and won a significant battle against the introduction of GM Bt brinjal or eggplant more than a decade ago.
That was in 2010, when then environment minister Jairam Ramesh heeded countrywide protests and imposed a moratorium on the release of Bt brinjal, citing inadequate environmental risk assessment tests as the major reason for his decision. Nothing has changed in India’s regulatory framework since then. So it was not surprising that the clearance granted to Pental’s GM mustard would provoke strong protests, more so over concerns that it is herbicide-tolerant, since it is based on the bar- barnase-barstar system. Scientists, all of them with expertise in several advanced disciplines of biology, plant breeding and environmental science, wrote open letters warning of the dangers of such a crop. These are not new concerns; they were raised earlier as well. In fact, the Supreme Court is hearing a petition against the release of dmh-11 and has sought more details on it.
هذه القصة من طبعة February 16, 2023 من Down To Earth.
اشترك في Magzter GOLD للوصول إلى آلاف القصص المتميزة المنسقة، وأكثر من 9000 مجلة وصحيفة.
هل أنت مشترك بالفعل؟ تسجيل الدخول
المزيد من القصص من Down To Earth
Down To Earth
MILES TO GO
As impacts of climate change accelerate, climate finance remains trapped in incrementalism
6 mins
April 16, 2026
Down To Earth
Hope for revival of the great Indian bustard
The birth of a great Indian bustard chick in the Kutch region of Gujarat has created history in the world of conservation, reviving hope.
2 mins
April 16, 2026
Down To Earth
IN MAHUA TERRITORY
Once mahua starts to flower, every thing else takes a back seat for tribal communities in forests of central India
6 mins
April 16, 2026
Down To Earth
CAUGHT IN THE ENERGY GAP
Kitchens across rural India reflect a peculiar reality: energy is within reach but affordability remains a concern. PUJA DAS travels across 15 villages in Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh and Uttar Pradesh to investigate why rural households still rely on traditional fuels like firewood, dung cakes and crop residue that pose a health risk, and why their energy bills are rising.
12 mins
April 16, 2026
Down To Earth
Lake or wetland?
While villages around Almora's Tadag Tal want the seasonal lake to be developed into a perennial waterbody, experts say the area is a wetland and should not be disturbed
5 mins
April 16, 2026
Down To Earth
World far from curbing maternal deaths
INDIA HAS cut its maternal mortality ratio (MMR) by 80 per cent since 1990, according to a recent analysis published in The Lancet.
1 min
April 16, 2026
Down To Earth
Energy in times of war
THE DISASTROUS US-Israel war against Iran has disrupted energy supply across the world. Governments in both rich and poor countries are warning their people of dire times ahead, unlike anything seen before by this generation: acute energy scarcity, rationing and even the prospect of cars and aeroplanes running out of fuel. The question is what will the future energy map look like?
3 mins
April 16, 2026
Down To Earth
Unfinished business
Land consolidation is globally considered a critical component of land reforms and holds the key to improve agrarian productivity. But it is yet to be undertaken in meaningful ways in most parts of the country, reports
6 mins
April 16, 2026
Down To Earth
Roots of revival
Chhattisgarh's Baiga community mounts conservation efforts to keep alive a traditional art form at risk of vanishing due to ecological changes
2 mins
April 16, 2026
Down To Earth
A mass human capital loss
ADULT HEIGHT across countries, including India, is no longer increasing.
2 mins
April 16, 2026
Translate
Change font size

