استمتع بـUnlimited مع Magzter GOLD

استمتع بـUnlimited مع Magzter GOLD

احصل على وصول غير محدود إلى أكثر من 9000 مجلة وصحيفة وقصة مميزة مقابل

$149.99
 
$74.99/سنة

يحاول ذهب - حر

'Dangerous to be funny' Has India lost its sense of humour?

January 12, 2024

|

The Guardian Weekly

It is rare for India's politicians to laugh at themselves, but a row over an act of mimicry has exposed the extent of the lack of humour and intolerance of satire in the country's political and public life.

- Amrit Dhillon

'Dangerous to be funny' Has India lost its sense of humour?

Politicians have traded insults over an impersonation of India's vicepresident, Jagdeep Dhankhar, by the opposition MP Kalyan Banerjee. He had mimicked Dhankhar's voice, walk and mannerisms on the steps of parliament last month during protests at his suspension from the lower house - along with 142 other opposition MPs - for alleged unruly behaviour.

Dhankhar, who is also chairman of the upper house of parliament, called Banerjee's performance, caught on video, "shameful, ridiculous and unacceptable".

The prime minister, Narendra Modi, reportedly phoned Dhankhar to express his pain over the incident, while Bharatiya Janata party (BJP) ministers attacked Banerjee for abusing the vice-president on the steps of the sacred "temple of democracy".

Banerjee insists that he has a right to freedom of expression and has called mimicry an art form. "If someone does not understand humour, if someone does not have a cultured mind, I am helpless," Banerjee said. "The arrogance of the BJP is so great it has lost its sense of humour. Humour is also a form of protest. Politics doesn't always have to be about fighting and arguing." Humour in India is dichotomous.

المزيد من القصص من The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

All things must pass

After a decade, Stranger Things is bowing out with an epic final season. Its creators and stars talk about big 80s hair, recruiting a Terminator killer-and the gift that Kate Bush sent them

time to read

7 mins

November 21, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

N344

Oyster mushroom skewers

time to read

1 min

November 21, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

Our lunch guests are always prompt... so where are they?

My wife and I are having people to lunch - another couple; old friends. It’s supposed to be an informal affair, but it’s been a long time in the planning because, unlike us, our guests are busy people, and hard to nail down.

time to read

2 mins

November 21, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

Vanity fair

This debut is a brilliant, chronically funny satire of the modern literary scene

time to read

1 mins

November 21, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

A strange miracle

A dreamlike novel from the Norwegian master's latest voyage into 'mystical realism'

time to read

3 mins

November 21, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

I'm vegetarian, he's a carnivore: what can I cook that we'll both like?

I'm a lifelong vegetarian, but my boyfriend is a dedicated carnivore. How can I cook to please us both? Victoria, by email

time to read

2 mins

November 21, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

Anthony Hopkins' autobiography mixes vulnerability with bloody mindedness

It's the greatest entrance in movie history and he doesn't move a muscle.

time to read

2 mins

November 21, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

The single mothers teaming up to raise kids

As divorce rates rise and the cost of living bites, single mothers in China are searching for a new kind of partner: each other.

time to read

3 mins

November 21, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

His master's voice

Anthony Hopkins' autobiography mixes vulnerability with bloody mindedness

time to read

2 mins

November 21, 2025

The Guardian Weekly

The Guardian Weekly

Oil the wheels Orbán claims a US victory - but is his grip slipping?

As Viktor Orbán would tell it, he had the perfect meeting with Donald Trump.

time to read

2 mins

November 21, 2025

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size