يحاول ذهب - حر
Austerity: How stoicism masks class power
April 17, 2025
|Mail & Guardian
The asceticism of the elite presents inequality as virtue, while the poor endure real deprivation
The rise of stoicism as a chic cultural trend among the middle and upper classes belies a deeper history of how self-denial and discipline serve as markers of class and tools of power.
Across Silicon Valley and global elites, chief executives and millionaires embrace spartan routines 5am wake-ups, intermittent fasting, cold showers in performative displays of stoic fortitude.
Ancient Stoic texts like Marcus Aurelius's Meditations have become staples of wellness blogs and chief executive book clubs. This contemporary stoicism is touted as a path to personal excellence.
Yet framed against the material realities of most people, the voluntary asceticism of the rich appears less as universal virtue and more as an assertion of elite identity.
This cultural turn is not happening in a vacuum. It emerges amid global polycrisis: inequality, ecological collapse, burnout and political cynicism. In this context, the call to regulate the self resonates with the middle and upper classes especially those seeking to protect their position.
But this turn inward also functions as depoliticisation. It substitutes self-mastery for social transformation, and inner calm for collective action.
More than a century ago, Marx reminded us that the ruling ideas in every epoch are those of the ruling class. Elite stoicism is no exception.
The notion that suffering should be endured in silence, that virtue lies in control rather than critique, forms part of an ideological apparatus that protects the powerful. When stoicism becomes a lifestyle aesthetic, it ceases to be a philosophy of endurance and becomes a moral alibi for injustice.
Stoicism, as it is popularly revived today, also carries a gendered ideal. The image of the stoic man unflinching, unemotional, master of his appetites repeats old patriarchal tropes about strength.
هذه القصة من طبعة April 17, 2025 من Mail & Guardian.
اشترك في Magzter GOLD للوصول إلى آلاف القصص المتميزة المنسقة، وأكثر من 9000 مجلة وصحيفة.
هل أنت مشترك بالفعل؟ تسجيل الدخول
المزيد من القصص من Mail & Guardian
Mail & Guardian
Mpondoland at the precipice
Its plight echoes a global call to remember who we are and what we stand to lose
5 mins
M&G 17 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
Namibia shifts gears in its journey to women in power
That changed with Netumbo Nandi-Ndaitwah. When she took the oath of office on 21 March, she did not just become Namibia’s first female president — she recalibrated the country’s idea of who belongs at the top.
3 mins
M&G 17 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
What Multichoice, Canal + deal means
This is the French media company's largest transaction
2 mins
M&G 17 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
Student wins bullying case
Amara Mooloo says the college launched disciplinary proceedings against her instead of addressing the claims
5 mins
M&G 17 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
Côte d'Ivoire vote relevant for region
Côte d'Ivoire's experience in handling electoral disputes through legal channels demonstrates the rule of law in action
4 mins
M&G 17 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
Paris, death destination of ambassadors past and present
Last week, as Spring dawned, the 5am news bulletin stopped me mid-step en route to my first cup of piping hot coffee.
6 mins
M&G 17 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
Sex pest teacher: Mom speaks out
Bereaved mother recalled her son's 2022 suicide as a 52-year-old former teacher at the school appeared in court this week on 25 counts of indecent assault and sexual assault of young boys
5 mins
M&G 17 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
Walk with us, President Ramaphosa
As with Marikana, the CR17 bank statements and Phala Phala — the biggest scandal of his presidency — Cyril Ramaphosa yet again finds himself in a pickle.
2 mins
M&G 17 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
When the lens sings
Vuyo Giba speaks about archiving South Africa's jazz legacy through black-and-white photography and reflects on Feya Faku's death
5 mins
M&G 17 October 2025
Mail & Guardian
Odinga: the relentless Pan-Africanist
Kenya's Raila Odinga, a pan-Africanist who dominated politics for half a century
5 mins
M&G 17 October 2025
Listen
Translate
Change font size

