يحاول ذهب - حر

The line was crossed with howler

May 28, 2025

|

Birmingham Mail

Furious Villa players surround referee Thomas Bramall

The line was crossed with howler

SETTING aside the rivalry that exists in football all over the world, surely all fans - win, lose, or draw - want to see fair play in a game we all love.

Villa had a justifiable complaint following their final-day Premier League defeat at Manchester United. Hand on heart, if it were against any of the clubs we support, we would be fuming.

All Blues fans will remember the FA Cup tie against Newcastle when a goal was given for the Magpies which had not crossed the line. That changed the course of the game, and it was the same at Old Trafford on Sunday.

Goals don’t just win games, they change them and having what looked like a perfectly good goal ruled out certainly changed the game for Villa and, quite possibly, denied them a place in next season’s Champions League.

Villa were not at their best on the day but that is not the issue. To go 1-0 up so late in the game would more than likely have changed the outcome. The referee incorrectly blowing his whistle before the ball had crossed the line bizarrely meant VAR could not get involved and that mystifies me.

The whole purpose of VAR is to ensure a “fair game” by rectifying any clear and obvious errors. Well, that looked pretty clear and obvious to everyone apart from the VAR, who was powerless to get involved because the referee had already blown his whistle before the ball had crossed the line.

An error that just needed the referee to go to the pitchside screen to review the incident where he would have seen the goal was valid. I am sure the PGMOL will have some way of explaining why this happened, probably with a ‘rules are rules’ attitude.

However, no amount of complaining will change a thing and Villa will have to dust themselves down and prepare for next season’s Premier League and Europa League campaigns.

المزيد من القصص من Birmingham Mail

Birmingham Mail

Bestselling author Trollope dies, 82

AUTHOR Joanna Trollope has died at the age of 82.

time to read

1 min

December 13, 2025

Birmingham Mail

Streeting 'fearful for NHS as strike looms'

WES Streeting has said he is \"genuinely fearful\" for the NHS if next week's strike by resident doctors goes ahead amid surging flu cases, agreeing the collapse of the health service is now \"effectively\" at \"one minute to midnight\".

time to read

2 mins

December 13, 2025

Birmingham Mail

Brum business boss backs 'Ozzy Osbourne Day' plan

A BIRMINGHAM business chief is throwing his weight behind calls to make July 22 the official 'Ozzy Osbourne Day'.

time to read

1 min

December 13, 2025

Birmingham Mail

There are twists and turns you don't see coming

Kym Marsh tells LYNN RUSK about filming in Australia for her new series The Imposter, which centres on a family dispute over their hotel's future

time to read

3 mins

December 13, 2025

Birmingham Mail

Birmingham Mail

Fiercely opposed green belt homes are green lit

COUNCIL SAYS HANDS WERE TIED OVER DEVELOPMENTS

time to read

2 mins

December 13, 2025

Birmingham Mail

Sixmilebridge continues to progress with triumph at Cheltenham

Chasing Excellence

time to read

2 mins

December 13, 2025

Birmingham Mail

Birmingham Mail

Baggies ease the pressure with comfortable home win

SECOND-HALF goals from Aune Heggebo and Karlan Grant set up a 2-0 win for West Brom against inform Sheffield United and relieved the pressure on head coach Ryan Mason.

time to read

2 mins

December 13, 2025

Birmingham Mail

It's an all-star Finish Line up

TV presenter Sarah Greene talks to YOLANTHE FAWEHINMI about her new celebrity-packed festive series of game show The Finish Line

time to read

4 mins

December 13, 2025

Birmingham Mail

Birmingham Mail

DIY festive foliage that's a real snip

LOOK TO THE GARDEN TO FIND ALL YOU NEED FOR BEAUTIFUL DECS

time to read

1 min

December 13, 2025

Birmingham Mail

Villa spirit hailed as Tielemans shines during statement win in Europe

ASTON Villa got the job done in Switzerland on Thursday night, beating FC Basel 2-1 at St. Jakob-Park.

time to read

3 mins

December 13, 2025

Listen

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size