يحاول ذهب - حر

Dear Immigration Restrictionists: Milton Friedman Was Not On Your Side

October 2018

|

Reason magazine

THE LATE NOBEL Prize–winning economist Milton Friedman was a free market libertarian who believed that immigrants helped make America great.

- Shikha Dalmia

Dear Immigration Restrictionists: Milton Friedman Was Not On Your Side

Yet he has become the restrictionist right’s weapon of choice to expunge the GOP’s pro-immigration faction.

It’s working. The Jack Kemp–style immigration champions are in complete retreat in the GOP, and the ultra restrictionists are on the march.

How has the latter group accomplished this feat? Partly by taking Friedman’s vague and general observation that free immigration is not compatible with the welfare state out of context and repeating it like a mantra at every opportunity. Not an hour goes by without some restrictionist somewhere—on blogs, social media, online comments sections—invoking Friedman’s comment to justify President Donald Trump’s aggressive border enforcement and push to slash immigration.

But these anti-immigrant conservatives are abusing Friedman. If they paid attention to his full remarks instead of conveniently cherry picking what suits them, they’d realize that far from cheering Trump’s draconian immigration crackdown, the great economist would be denouncing Trump as a colossal fool.

Friedman is rightly venerated by conservatives for his path-breaking academic work and his popular PBS series

المزيد من القصص من Reason magazine

Reason magazine

Reason magazine

A Nostalgic Read for Foreign Policy Elites

IF YOU WERE looking for a human avatar of America's unipolar moment, you couldn't do better than Michael McFaul. Picture a youthful, energetic McFaul with a newly minted Ph.D. bounding into the suddenly post-Soviet space of the early 1990s, full of bright ideas about democracy and faith in the end of history. As McFaul himself puts it, 1991 \"was a glorious moment to be a democratic, liberal, capitalist, multilateralist, and American....I was treated like a rockstar.\"

time to read

4 mins

January 2026

Reason magazine

Reason magazine

TRUMP IS DEPORTING ENTREPRENEURS

THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION'S MASS DEPORTATION EFFORT IS ROBBING THE U.S. OF IMMIGRANT BUSINESS OWNERS AND THEIR CONTRIBUTIONS.

time to read

9 mins

January 2026

Reason magazine

The First Information Revolution

PRINTING PRESSES AND LIBRARIANS INTERPRETED CENSORSHIP AS DAMAGE AND ROUTED AROUND IT.

time to read

11 mins

January 2026

Reason magazine

Reason magazine

What Would Bill Buckley Do?

THE NATIONAL REVIEW FOUNDER'S FLEXIBLE APPROACH TO POLITICS DEFINED CONSERVATISM AS WE KNOW IT.

time to read

7 mins

January 2026

Reason magazine

Reason magazine

MAHA Mandates Food Labels

BURDENSOME FOOD LABELING mandates were once the province of Democrats, who pushed for calorie count requirements on restaurant menus and insisted packaged food must feature warnings about genet- ically modified ingredients and trans fats. Now it's Republicans leading the charge- with equally foolish results.

time to read

2 mins

January 2026

Reason magazine

Reason magazine

IS JAKE TAPPER DOOMED?

THE CNN ANCHOR ON THE WAR ON TERROR, THREATS TO FREE SPEECH, AND THE FUTURE OF MEDIA

time to read

14 mins

January 2026

Reason magazine

Reason magazine

REPUBLICAN SOCIALISM

THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION IS BUYING STAKES IN COMPANIES. THAT NEVER ENDS WELL.

time to read

13 mins

January 2026

Reason magazine

Reason magazine

A Taste of Capitalism in Warsaw

WARSAW, POLAND, IS a living museum of economic systems. It's a city where concrete reliefs of stoic factory workers decorate a building that now houses a Kentucky Fried Chicken, where a Soviet-era apartment block stands beside a glass tower filled with coworking spaces.

time to read

2 mins

January 2026

Reason magazine

Reason magazine

Robert Crumb's Roving Art and Life

IN THE SPRING of 1962, an 18-year-old Robert Crumb was beaned in the forehead by a solid glass ashtray. His mother, Bea, had hurled it at his father, Chuck, who ducked. Robert was bloodied and dazed, once again a silent and enraged witness to his family's chaos.”

time to read

5 mins

January 2026

Reason magazine

Reason magazine

THE HOWARD ROARK OF COMICS

SPIDER-MAN CO-CREATOR STEVE DITKO WAS A GREAT EXAMPLE OF, AND DIRE WARNING TO, OBJECTIVIST POP ARTISTS.

time to read

12 mins

January 2026

Translate

Share

-
+

Change font size