Lower judicial officers seek reforms in their evaluation process, alleging manipulation, mismanagement and lack of transparency.
On October 6, 2016, the Supreme Court pulled up the Delhi High Court over a plea filed by Barkha Gupta, a judicial officer from a lower court in the capital. She had challenged the inferior grading she was given in her Annual Confidential Reports (ACRs are used to decide on promotion and transfer); Gupta was given a ‘C’, which stood for ‘integrity doubtful’. The two-judge Supreme Court bench, comprising Justices Ranjan Gogoi and Prafulla C. Pant, said the remarks recorded in her ACRs between 1999 and 2004 were “wholly unsustainable in law”. Even as she was given a ‘C’ grading, she was continued in service and promoted as additional district judge. The grading was given to her, as is the practice in Delhi’s judicial setup, by a full bench of the High Court.
In June 2015, Additional District and Sessions Judge Sujata Kohli moved Delhi High Court, challenging the “non-transparent” criteria adopted by the High Court. Kohli, who joined the Delhi Judicial Services in 2002, standing third in the merit list, was agitated over being ignored for promotion and her juniors getting promoted as district and sessions judges. She said that the High Court had repeatedly changed the criteria for promotion and not informed judicial officers about it.
In 2009, the Delhi High Court had laid down that a judicial officer must have at least one A rating in the ACR in five years to be considered for promotion. It was changed in 2010 and again in 2011 to make it five As in five years.
“The HC has not given due weight to seniority, which was a criterion when petitioner was appointed/ selected to the cadre of district judge. Unfortunately, over the last few years, the HC has been continuously altering the criteria for promotion... which are not even communicated to the additional district judges,” Kohli said in her petition.
Bu hikaye THE WEEK dergisinin June 24, 2018 sayısından alınmıştır.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Giriş Yap
Bu hikaye THE WEEK dergisinin June 24, 2018 sayısından alınmıştır.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Giriş Yap
There Is A Wind Blowing Against The BJP, And It Will Only Pick Up Speed
Interview - Akhilesh Yadav, Former Chief Minister, Uttar Pradesh
Between hospital and home
Transitional care centres can add a lot to India's health care system
EFFORT VS EFFECT
The government's attempts to ensure quality drugs is evident, but how well new policies can be monitored on the ground remains to be seen
A way to let go of fear
Accepting the use of adult diapers is a journey with various stages-denial, concealment, rejection and reluctance
Mandeeps & a miracle
Two strangers, one deadly disease and an act of kindness. How Mandeep Mann saved Mandeep Singh, an acute leukaemia patient, by donating his stem cells
The A, B, C of cosmetic surgery
Between eight to 10 lakh cosmetic surgeries happen in India every year. Who is an ideal candidate, and what are the risks and results you can expect?
Vaccines and meningitis
In sub-Saharan Africa, from Senegal in the west to Ethiopia in the east, and encompassing the northern part of Nigeria, there exists a region known as the African Meningitis Belt (AMB).
Celebrating diversity and inclusivity
As Indians battle it out in our nation's 18th general election, it is again time for voters to reflect on the \"Idea of India\"-or rather, on two duelling ideas of India that are now before us and between which the nation must choose at the ballot box.
Defendant: an Hermès handbag
When Hermès was hit with a class-action lawsuit last month for \"antitrust\" activities, it didn't see it coming. Most of the luxury world has all eyes on this suit, filed by two interested consumers who claim they were denied a purchase, and whether it would go to trial.
A legacy, bound
Amal Allana's biography of her father, Ebrahim Alkazi, is as much personal as it is historical