At teaching hospitals, medical students regularly perform pelvic exams (and occasionally prostate exams) on unconscious patients, who might never know. Does it matter? Jennifer Tsai, MD, examines where the contemporary understanding of consent confronts the conventions of academic medicine.
In 2016, Carrie Flynn had just started her first clinical rotation for the Yale School of Medicine. For six weeks, she would work in Bridgeport Hospital’s ob-gyn department, during which time she’d be shepherded in and out of operating rooms by residents and attending physicians. Flynn, then 28, rarely met patients before their surgeries. Instead, the third-year student would often show up at an operating room, where the female patient was already unconscious, and observe or perform whatever maneuver her superiors requested. (She remembers once asking if she could pre-round on patients before surgery in order to introduce herself. She was told no.)
Flynn once performed a pelvic exam on a woman who was under anesthesia. This involves placing two fingers into the vagina while a second hand is placed on the patient’s abdomen to feel for ovaries, masses, and uterine mobility. Pelvic exams, a regular part of gynecological visits, are necessary before gynecological surgery, as they allow physicians to examine anatomy before performing procedures like hysterectomies and fibroid removals. At teaching hospitals, where medical students are involved in patient care, students regularly perform these exams for educational training. They’re often the third or fourth person to conduct the procedure, after an attending physician and one or two residents. Flynn had not met the female patient before she inserted her fingers into her vagina. She didn’t know if the patient even knew she was in the room. “I’m certain [she] did not give consent,” Flynn says now, three years later. “I would be shocked if the [resident or attending] did on my behalf.”
Bu hikaye ELLE dergisinin August 2019 sayısından alınmıştır.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Giriş Yap
Bu hikaye ELLE dergisinin August 2019 sayısından alınmıştır.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Giriş Yap
MUSIC for This MOMENT
Featuring NORMANI, GRACIE ABRAMS, FLO MILLI, COCO JONES
Ms. Bright Side
For Dua Lipa, queen of the dance floor and everyone's big sister, life is only worth living if you're having fun.
SUMMER SOUNDS
Meet the breakthrough artists you'll have on repeat.
JEWEL WILL STILL SAVE YOUR SOUL
Artifice is out, mental health is in, and Jewel's been ready for this moment her entire life.
BODY BY BOTOX
Barbie neck. Angular shoulders. And a long-lasting back massage? Injections are no longer just for your face.
The MAGIC of CHARLOTTE TILBURY
The world's most beguiling makeup artist on beauty, stars, love, and sex.
ONLY IN VENICE
As the Venice Biennale marks its 60th edition, the city's art scene has never been more vibrant.
RISE & SHINE
Van Cleef & Arpels's Poetic Complications collection is the ultimate pick-me-up.
GREATEST HITS
Musicians are revisiting their fashion \"eras\"-and with them, their pasts.
THEY'RE WITH THE BAND
Thanks to groups like Blackpink and boygenius, musicians' synchronized dressing has reached new heights.