Dirk De Wolf and Tom Boonen’s Colnago-bashing Wielerclub Wattage podcast, in which De Wolf claimed there was a 2kph difference between the Italian brand’s new V4Rs bike and the best competitor WorldTour bikes, made the biggest headlines when Colnago struck back. Rather than waving a white flag, Colnago instead waved its white paper: “Here is our data. Where is yours?”
The exchange served to reinforce the position of the white paper in today’s bike industry. Namely, if you are going to make particular claims you’d better be able to back them up with data.
Boonen climbed down and apologised, despite being invited to Cambiago for a “public conversation”.
“I was hoping to be able to ride with Tom,” says Colnago’s head of R&D Davide Fumagalli. “I always admired him for the way he raced.”
However, Fumagalli is less impressed with the 2kph claim, actually made by De Wolf, not Boonen, he emphasises.
“If you ride a bike and you say ‘I don’t like it, this one’s too stiff, not stiff enough, too heavy, too light’ that’s fair enough. But if you say ‘this bike is 2kph slower than that one’ you have to prove it.”
According to Fumagalli, a white paper is not a tool to communicate the new bike – the white paper actually is the new bike. It is the collection of the information about the bike, “an open share of information”.
However, for the onlooker enjoying the spat, it’s slightly disappointing that Colnago’s white paper doesn’t prove for its part that the V4Rs is faster than the bikes De Wolf mentioned (the Cervélo S5 and R5, Pinarello Dogma F and Specialized Tarmac SL7). Why not?
This story is from the April 13, 2023 edition of Cycling Weekly.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the April 13, 2023 edition of Cycling Weekly.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Is pro racing getting more dangerous?
There are many factors that contribute to the perceived greater risks. One that does not get any attention is the greater importance of UCI points and the need to constantly collect them to avoid relegation.
A Saturday in Hell
It's the most brutal race of the year - 29.2km of the worst cobbles northern France has to offer, over 17 agonising sectors, starting in Denain and finishing in the iconic Roubaix velodrome. For the men, it's referred to as a Sunday in Hell, but for us, hell comes a day early.
Gitane - Tour de l'Avenir
Classic French brand's homage to a revered amateur race
6 WAYS TO THINK YOURSELF FASTER
However flawless your physical preparation, the mind has a tendency to throw a spanner in the works come the big day. James Witts offers six ways to keep the brain onside with the body
MAURICE BURTON'S - SCHOOL OF HARD KNOCKS
9 life lessons from Britain's first Black cycling champion
PEAKS PRACTICE
The Peak District is home turf for Manchester-based British pro riders and has been the formative terrain of top domestic riders for decades. Adam Becket finds out why it's so effective
Zeb Kyffin: stepping out of the fish bowl
TDT-Unibet's British rider tasted the team's first World-Tour event at the Amstel Gold Race. Adam Becket finds out how the day went
Thomas to go for 'very top step' at Giro
Welshman and Ineos ready for duel with Tadej Pogačar, reports Adam Becket
Brown and Niewiadoma beat Vollering
SD Worx-Protime are far from unbeatable in 2024, as team misses out in Ardennes Classics
Pogačar lays down marker for Giro d'Italia
Liège win signals Slovenian's readiness for clash with Geraint Thomas, reports Adam Becket