The England conducted investigation" and Wales Cricket board a "woefully inadequate into Michael Vaughan that displayed "actual bias" and was "an affront to fairness", the final day of the Yorkshire racism hearing was told.
In his closing submission the former England captain's legal counsel, Christopher Stoner KC, questioned why the ECB had initially withheld a statement from Ajmal Shahzad that backed Vaughan's claims he had never uttered the phrase "there are too many of you lot" to four Asian players before a Twenty20 game in 2009. Stoner also raised concerns to the Cricket Discipline Commission that the ECB had not spoken to the umpires, cameramen or many of the players at the game before charging Vaughan.
"The investigation in this case was woefully inadequate," he said. "Due process matters and it is the cornerstone of law. But in our submission it was sent on holiday by the ECB. It raises a real question of fairness, which Mr Vaughan has not been afforded.
This story is from the March 08, 2023 edition of The Guardian.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the March 08, 2023 edition of The Guardian.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Rashford needs redemption at Wembley to salvage season
Striker's career of wild peaks and troughs requires a strong performance against City after his latest England blow
Ford-Robinson calm as Sharks begin to circle
Jamal Ford-Robinson is detailing what the award he won at Gloucester's end of season bash was for when eventually he explains that \"essentially it's about being a good club man\".
Capsey leads way for unconvincing England
Alice Capsey hit a career-best 44 from 65 balls as England comfortably beat Pakistan by 37 runs in the first one-day international against Pakistan at Derby.
Tambourine man Why our happy band at Grimsby will keep sharing spotlight as we focus on future
I'n the 1980s, a big night out meant my brothers and mates donning our shiny shirts, necking several pints of Tennent's, then shuffling around the dancefloor of Pier 39 nightclub in Cleethorpes to the sound of George Benson's Give Me the Night.
'Kleptocracy walking tour' MP goes on the trail of dirty money
Margaret Hodge, the veteran Labour MP and former minister, is knocking on doors of multimillion-pound London properties.
Watchdog launches formal investigation into vets' fees
The UK competition regulator has launched a formal investigation into the £2bn veterinary market, over concerns that pet owners could be overpaying for medicines and may not always be aware of the best treatment options available.
US denies UK claim that China is giving 'lethal aid' to Russia
Joe Biden's administration has challenged a claim by the British defence secretary, Grant Shapps, that China is sending \"lethal aid❞ to Russia for use in its war in Ukraine.
China launches two days of 'punishment' drills after Taiwanese president sworn in
Dozens of Chinese fighter jets carried out mock strikes against Taiwanese targets yesterday as \"punishment\" after Taiwan inaugurated a new president, China's military said.
Hostages Families of five women release video of kidnaps in call for deal
An Israeli group representing the families of hostages held in Gaza has released footage showing the capture of five female soldiers from a military base during the 7 October Hamas attacks.
Court case New ruling expected on conduct of war in Gaza
The International Court of justice (ICJ) is expected to issue a new ruling on Israel's conduct of its war in Gaza this afternoon, as the US expressed concern over Israel's growing diplomatic isolation among countries that have traditionally supported it.