Cruel performative policies are being used as a smokescreen
The Guardian Weekly|November 17, 2023
This week, Britain's supreme court was due to give its verdict on the Rwanda deportation scheme. The decision will clearly have a major impact on those who face deportation. It will have an impact, too, on the political debate about immigration.
Kenan Malik
Cruel performative policies are being used as a smokescreen

But, whatever the decision, it will have little bearing on the "immigration crisis". The government itself has acknowledged that, even were the court to deem the scheme legal, and deportation flights to Kigali take off, Rwanda could take only "small numbers" of deportees, possibly 300 a year across the four years of the trial period. Given that there were almost 46,000 people crossing the Channel on small boats last year, and that by August this year the asylum backlog stood at 175,000, the deportation scheme amounts to little more than performative policy - the desire to be seen doing something and doing something cruel - rather than a serious attempt to tackle a problem.

Performative policymaking has become commonplace in immigration management, and not just in Britain. Last week, Italy's prime minister, Giorgia Meloni, announced an arrangement under which undocumented migrants and asylum seekers will be kept in specially built detention centres in Albania.

The details are sketchy, but the scheme appears to be a form of offshore processing, whereby those heading for Italy but intercepted in international waters are to be detained in Albania and their cases heard there. The judges overseeing the cases will, however, be Italian and will sit in courtrooms deemed to be under Italian jurisdiction. If found to be genuine, asylum seekers would be free to move to Italy. Those who lose their cases would face deportation.

This story is from the November 17, 2023 edition of The Guardian Weekly.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the November 17, 2023 edition of The Guardian Weekly.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM THE GUARDIAN WEEKLYView All
Ours is an age of confusion. How should we navigate it? Timothy Garton Ash
The Guardian Weekly

Ours is an age of confusion. How should we navigate it? Timothy Garton Ash

In these times of planetary polycrisis, we try to get our bearings by looking to the past. Are we perhaps in The New Cold War, as Robin.

time-read
4 mins  |
May 10, 2024
The world according to Jason
The Guardian Weekly

The world according to Jason

Covid vaccines, chemtrails, the Great Reset... Why do people invent false conspiracies when there are so many real ones to worry about? There's only one way to find out: George Monbiot asked a believer from his home town

time-read
10+ mins  |
May 10, 2024
From a small step for man to a giant gold rush for mankind
The Guardian Weekly

From a small step for man to a giant gold rush for mankind

If the 20th-century space race was about political power, this century's will be about money. But for those who dream of sending humans back to the moon and possibly Mars, it's an exciting time to be alive whether it's presidents or billionaires paying the fare.

time-read
3 mins  |
May 10, 2024
A bitter pill Inside the anti-doping movement's civil war
The Guardian Weekly

A bitter pill Inside the anti-doping movement's civil war

Furore over Chinese swimmers has sparked an ugly dispute between organisations that target athletes who use banned substances

time-read
5 mins  |
May 10, 2024
Museum of Yoruba life is custommade for Lagos
The Guardian Weekly

Museum of Yoruba life is custommade for Lagos

Opposite the Nigerian National Museum in central Lagos, a swimming pool and a memorial hall once stood as an integral part of the city, a popular congregation point that evoked a sense of pride.

time-read
3 mins  |
May 10, 2024
First steps for Nutbush Quest goes on for origin of line dance
The Guardian Weekly

First steps for Nutbush Quest goes on for origin of line dance

For 50 years, Australian primary school students have been learning the steps to a dance that will carry them through social events and weddings and allow them to locate other Australians across crowded nightclubs anywhere in the world.

time-read
3 mins  |
May 10, 2024
Press freedom How political attacks are rising globally
The Guardian Weekly

Press freedom How political attacks are rising globally

Political attacks on press freedom, including the detention of journalists, suppression of independent media outlets and widespread dissemination of misinformation, have significantly intensified in the past year, according to the annual World Press Freedom Index published by Reporters Without Borders (RSF).

time-read
2 mins  |
May 10, 2024
Rio reporters risking all to shine light on the city's underworld
The Guardian Weekly

Rio reporters risking all to shine light on the city's underworld

A brutal killing in 2018 has inspired journalists to probe the links between police, politicians and mafia

time-read
3 mins  |
May 10, 2024
Is great ape tourism to blame for killing off chimps?
The Guardian Weekly

Is great ape tourism to blame for killing off chimps?

Viruses that only cause common colds in humans are devastating populations of chimpanzees and gorillas

time-read
5 mins  |
May 10, 2024
Dig for disaster Calls to move to centre or right won't help Sunak out of this hole
The Guardian Weekly

Dig for disaster Calls to move to centre or right won't help Sunak out of this hole

As terrible council and mayoral results rolled in for the Conservatives last Friday, was there any part of Rishi Sunak that regretted sealing Boris Johnson's fate as prime minister by resigning as his chancellor less than two years ago?

time-read
2 mins  |
May 10, 2024