But in 1986, that really happened. Clive Wilson's stooping header and an Arthur Albiston own goal earned City an unlikely point against United, and the following day they went down 5-4 against Chelsea in the inaugural Full Members Cup final.
Lillis thought he had scored a fourminute hat-trick, the fastest in Wembley history, in City's late rally from 5-1 down.
But he only discovered one of his goals had been chalked up as an own goal when he asked referee Alan Saunders for the match ball and found he had given it to David Speedie, who had scored his own treble for the winning side.
When City and Chelsea meet in the FA Cup semi-final today, it is fair to assume the players will be more fresh than their Wembley predecessors from 38 years ago.
Lillis, now 64 and working for City's academy, said: "When I tell people now that we drew the Manchester derby 2-2 at Old Trafford and then I scored twice in a Wembley final the next day, they look at me and wonder if I've lost the plot.
This story is from the April 20, 2024 edition of Daily Mirror UK.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the April 20, 2024 edition of Daily Mirror UK.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
KAABI TAKES VILLA FOR A RIDE
Moroccan striker stuns Villa with a hat-trick as Emery's men now have to wipe out a two-goal deficit in Greece
THE GLAD HATTER
Lockyer admits he's accepted heart emergency may have ended his career & says: I know now I'm lucky to still be here
RONNIE: I'M NO BULLY
O'Sullivan reacts angrily to social-media flak after his latest rumpus with ref
DRAGONS WIG WHAM
Fightback Warriors show Catalans who's boss
SUNK IN JUST SIX MINUTES
Grandchildren of Navy captain in Bismarck tragedy sell heirlooms
I knew Nora was going ..but I was like, no way
Johnny Rotten's tears on tour as he recalls death of beloved wife Catch more that
She wanted to kick my butt, I wanted to kick hers.. No regrets
Tessa's feud with Fatima not fully sorted 40yrs on
Grieving families prepare 2nd sad farewells
DNA tests mean funerals can begin
GET FIT.. BY 55
More active middle-age women will enjoy healthier later life, says study
Stop the bus
45 arrests as protesters block Bibby barge migrant coach