Irishman Brian MacNeice wasn’t the most popular man in Edinburgh last night after his deliberations for fully four minutes prompted referee Nic Berry to disallow what would have been a winning try for Scotland replacement Sam Skinner in the final play of the match.
Up in the Scots’ coaching box and around the ground, supporters started to celebrate as replays appeared to show the Edinburgh lock had grounded the ball after a last-ditch onslaught on the French line.
But Berry, who had a decent view at ground level, decided he couldn’t give a try based on what he could see and referred it upstairs.
During the course of the conversation that followed, the Australian whistler appeared to change his mind at one point before being directed to a different angle by MacNeice and ultimately deciding he didn’t have “conclusive evidence” to overturn his original ‘no-try’ verdict.
Cue frustration and dejection from the hosts and elation from the French, who ended a harrowing week with a precious Six Nations victory that had looked beyond them for most of this contest.
After their crushing opening defeat by Ireland in Marseille, there was plenty more vulnerability on show here but Fabien Galthie’s side showed character and composure to fight back in the final quarter.
With a home match against Italy next, their campaign is back on the rails while Scotland’s hopes of launching a title challenge suffered a major setback.
When Finn Russell’s third penalty put them 16- 10 ahead just before the hour, they appeared to be heading for victory but ultimately they could not close out the contest and paid a heavy price.
この記事は The Rugby Paper の February 11, 2024 版に掲載されています。
7 日間の Magzter GOLD 無料トライアルを開始して、何千もの厳選されたプレミアム ストーリー、8,500 以上の雑誌や新聞にアクセスしてください。
すでに購読者です ? サインイン
この記事は The Rugby Paper の February 11, 2024 版に掲載されています。
7 日間の Magzter GOLD 無料トライアルを開始して、何千もの厳選されたプレミアム ストーリー、8,500 以上の雑誌や新聞にアクセスしてください。
すでに購読者です? サインイン
Army leave it late to regain trophy
MOMENTS and minutes change matches in equal measure, and that is exactly what happened at Kingsholm as the British Army’s men regained the Inter Service Championship trophy.
Blues hold on in battle at the top
BLUES held on with their backs to their try line as they edged past the Hurricanes 31-27 to leapfrog their Kiwi rivals and move top of the table.
Harrison leads from front to seal it for Saracens
SARACENS returned to Allianz PWR action with a bonus-point win at StoneX Stadium.
Coventry denied by powerful Pirates
SHEER pack power delivered two classic late rolling maul tries as Pirates maintained their quest for a second place Championship finish.
Davies the leading light in Welsh quartet
FOUR international flyhalves took flight from Wales last year, understandably so given the alternative of staying put on contracts shredded by the rugby recession.
Rugby's holy trinity prove the difference
SINCE time immemorial, rugby has been cloaked in its own cliches: Prince Obolensky was always “dashing”; Colin Meads lived his life as an “unsmiling giant”; Martin Johnson was rarely anything other than “beetle-browed”; and Billy Vunipola, easier to stop with an elephant gun than he is with a Taser according to recent evidence from a late-night bar in Mallorca, will forever be known as “the man who shamed the shirt he wasn’t wearing”.
Tbilisi win was key - Skivington
GEORGE Skivington has credited the European Challenge Cup win against Black Lion in Tbilisi as the moment Gloucester turned their season around.
Scarlets pay price for lack of discipline
ULSTER gave their URC play-off hopes a major boost as they capitalised on indiscipline from the hosts to secure maximum points in Llanelli.
James at his best as Sale keep in the race
SAM James might be departing for pastures new but Sale’s Mr Dependable produced a nigh on immaculate performance at full-back as they continue to battle for a play-off place.
Russell masterclass has Bath in top gear
FINN Russell scored eight points, pulled the strings for three of Bath’s tries and barely put a foot wrong in a classy display that will send shivers down the spine of their Premiership title rivals.